How to Use Automatic Selection Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To use Automatic Selection in Procreate, tap the Selection button, choose Automatic, and tap the area you want. Procreate selects that region of the active layer based on color. After tapping, press and hold and drag left or right to shrink or grow the selection with the threshold. Tap more areas to add them, then switch to any other tool to commit the selection and start editing.
For motion designers and animators, this is Procreate's magic wand. It is a quick way to isolate shapes, build mattes, or prep character art before it goes into After Effects, Blender, or Nuke. The sections below cover the full workflow, the threshold control that makes it usable, the layer limitation that trips up many people coming from other software, and how to troubleshoot it.
What Automatic Selection Does in Procreate
Automatic Selection picks a contiguous area of pixels based on color. Tap a flat blue shape and Procreate selects the blue region around your finger or Apple Pencil. It behaves much like ColorDrop, and it shares the same threshold behavior.
The tool reads only the layer you're working on. Whatever is on the active layer determines where the selection edge lands. Content on other layers is ignored, which matters for anyone who keeps line art, flats, and backgrounds separate.
It works best on art with clear color boundaries: flat illustration, vector-style shapes, line art with closed outlines, and graphic style frames. It is less predictable on textured paintings, gradients, and soft brushwork, where the color boundaries are fuzzy.
Step-by-Step: Making an Automatic Selection
1. Open the Selection toolbar and choose Automatic
Tap the Selection button to bring up the Selection toolbar. Choose Automatic from the modes. The other modes are Freehand, Rectangle, and Ellipse.
2. Tap the area you want
Tap inside the region you want to select. Procreate shows the selection as the tool computes it. The Handbook notes the selected area appears in inverted colors while you work, so a large blue area looks yellow. Use that preview to judge whether the edge is landing where you expect.
3. Adjust the threshold
Immediately after tapping, press and hold and drag your finger or Pencil left or right. This invokes Selection Threshold.
- Drag left to reduce the selection and make it stricter about which colors count.
- Drag right to expand it. As you push higher, the selection starts flowing into neighboring areas, and at the extreme it can take over the whole layer.
A percentage readout appears as you drag, like the one in ColorDrop. If you've used ColorDrop, you already know how this feels.
One detail is easy to miss: the threshold only applies to the current tap. If you lift your Pencil and tap another area, you start a new addition rather than changing the earlier threshold. Dial in each region before you move on.
4. Add more areas
Keep tapping other areas on the canvas, and Automatic mode adds each one to the selection. You can also switch to Freehand, Rectangle, or Ellipse and add shapes in those modes. Set the mode to Add if you're mixing methods.
5. Refine with Freehand
Procreate's own advice is to make a rough pick with Automatic, then switch to Freehand for fine adjustments. This is the fastest way to clean up stray pixels, fill a gap, or trim an edge that the threshold can't resolve.
You can use undo and redo gestures within the active selection while you refine it.
6. Commit the selection
When the selection looks right, tap any other tool. When you see semi-transparent, moving diagonal lines outside the selected area, the selection has been committed. At that point you can:
- Paint, smudge, or erase within the selection
- ColorDrop into it
- Transform it
7. Cancel if needed
To drop the selection and return to your artwork, tap the Selection button again.
Watch the Color Fill Toggle
The Selection toolbar includes a Color Fill option. When it's active, it shows blue and fills the selection with your current color the moment you make it. That's handy for flats and a surprise if you only wanted to isolate a region. If your shape suddenly changes color, check this toggle first.
Tuning the Selection Mask Visibility
Committed selections display as diagonal lines over the area outside the selection. If they're too faint or too heavy for your screen and room lighting, open Settings > Preferences > Selection Mask Visibility and adjust the slider. Some artists keep it around 30%, but the right value depends on the artwork and your iPad's brightness.
Working Across Multiple Layers
This is where artists coming from Clip Studio Paint or SAI run into trouble. Those programs offer a magic wand option that can sample all layers. Procreate's Automatic Selection works on one layer at a time. Selecting multiple layers by swiping doesn't change that, and the Reference layer feature only supports a single layer. In community discussions, multi-layer reference has been listed as not planned, so build your workflow around the limitation.
The flattened-reference workaround
Here is a workaround some Procreate users rely on:
- Duplicate the layers whose edges you want to respect, such as all your line art layers.
- Merge the duplicates into one layer.
- Hide that merged layer if you like.
- Set it as the Reference layer.
- Switch to the layer you want to color or select on and use Automatic Selection or ColorDrop.
The selection will now follow the edges of the merged reference layer instead of whatever is on the active layer. You keep your original layers intact because you only merged copies. It adds a few steps, but it lets you color under line art without flattening your file.
If you want everything considered, copy the whole drawing onto a new layer and use that as the reference.
Fixing Common Problems
The whole canvas gets selected
The most common complaint is that a tap selects the entire canvas, even when the line art looks closed. Usually the threshold is set too high. Try this:
- While Select is active, drag left to bring the threshold down toward 0%, but not all the way.
- Turn Select off, then turn it on again.
- Tap the area again.
- If the selection fills where you want, raise the threshold in small steps.
If it still selects everything, repeat the reset. If the result is inconsistent, also check that you're on the correct layer and that the outline has no tiny gaps. A single open pixel in a line lets the selection leak out into the rest of the layer.
The selection ignores the line art
You're probably on a different layer than the line art, with no reference set. Either work on the line art layer or use the reference workaround above.
Jagged or halo edges
Automatic Selection tracks color thresholds, so anti-aliased edges can leave a fringe. Lower the threshold a bit, or add a small cleanup pass with Freehand. If the result is destined for compositing, check the edge at 100% zoom or larger before you export.
Practical Uses for Motion and VFX Artists
Automatic Selection isn't a rotoscoping tool, but it helps with design and prep work in a motion pipeline:
- Style frames and boards: Isolate shapes and recolor palettes quickly while exploring looks for a client.
- Character and element separation: Select flat color regions, copy them to new layers, and build separated elements for rigging in After Effects or Blender.
- Quick mattes: Select a shape, fill it with solid white on its own layer over black, and export it as a simple matte for compositing.
- Texture and background prep: Cut out shapes to use as textures or overlays in Cinema 4D or Nuke.
For exports, hide layers you don't want, save as PNG so transparency survives, and import into After Effects or Nuke. For separated elements, export each as its own file so compositing stays flexible.
Quick Reference
- Start: Selection button → Automatic → tap the area.
- Adjust: Press and hold, then drag left (tighter) or right (looser).
- Add: Keep tapping, or switch modes.
- Refine: Use Freehand for edge cleanup.
- Commit: Tap any other tool and look for moving diagonal lines.
- Cancel: Tap the Selection button again.
- Multi-layer fix: Merge duplicates of the layers you need, then use the result as the Reference layer.
- Whole canvas selected: Lower the threshold, toggle Select off and on, and try again.
Automatic Selection is simple once you understand two rules: it reads one layer, and the threshold controls everything. Get those right and it becomes a fast starting point for any artwork headed into your motion pipeline.