How to to Select Based on All Layers in Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
Procreate's Automatic Selection and Color Drop only read one layer at a time: the active layer, or a single layer set as Reference. To select based on all layers, duplicate the artwork you want it to respect, merge the duplicates into one new layer, hide it, and set that layer as the Reference. Automatic Selection and Color Drop will then treat everything in that merged layer as one image, while your original layers stay untouched.
Why Procreate Won't Sample All Layers
If you come from Photoshop, Clip Studio Paint, or SAI, you expect a "sample all layers" checkbox on the magic wand and bucket tools. Procreate doesn't have one. Automatic Selection and Color Drop evaluate pixels on the layer you're working on, or on the one layer you've flagged as Reference. Swiping right to multi-select layers doesn't change this, and neither does turning Reference on when your drawing is spread across several layers.
Long-time users have described this as how the app works, and the request for multi-layer sampling has been marked as not planned. So the practical approach is to build the layer you want it to read, not to hunt for a hidden setting.
Method 1: Build a Merged Reference Layer
This is a common workaround among Procreate users.
- Duplicate the layers you want to sample. For coloring, that's usually every line art layer: character, props, background lines. If you want to respect color shapes as well, duplicate those too.
- Merge the duplicates into one layer. Multi-select them by tapping one layer and swiping right on the others, then tap Merge. Do this on the duplicates only.
- Hide the merged layer. Toggle its visibility checkbox. Hidden layers still work as references.
- Set it as Reference. Tap the layer, open Layer Options, and tap Reference.
- Select your target layer (the one you want to paint on, usually below the lines) and use Color Drop or Automatic Selection. Both now respect the combined line work.
Because the merged layer is just a flattened copy, your original layers stay editable. If you change the line art later, delete the old merged copy and rebuild it.
Quick version: flatten a copy of the whole canvas
If you want the reference to reflect everything visible, copy the whole drawing and paste it as a new layer, which effectively flattens the canvas onto a single layer. Make that layer the Reference and hide it. This is faster than duplicating layer by layer, but it bakes in colors and shading as well as lines, which can make selections less clean for coloring.
Method 2: A Dedicated Line Art Reference for Coloring
For illustration and cel-style coloring, a purpose-built reference works better than a full flatten.
- Keep a single "Ref – Lines" layer that holds only the merged line art.
- Put flat colors on separate layers underneath. Color Drop on those layers will stop at the lines in the reference.
- If lines are solid and closed, Color Drop works cleanly. If you see color leaking, increase the Color Drop threshold by dragging, or close the gap on a layer used only for the reference. Don't alter your final line art for this.
- Rebuild the reference whenever you revise the lines. Consider naming it clearly and keeping it at the top of the stack so it's easy to find and refresh.
A useful trick: add a hard-edged, high-contrast "gap closer" layer, painted in a different color, and merge it into the reference copy only. Your visible art stays clean while the selection logic sees closed shapes.
Method 3: Select the Contents of Layers Instead of Sampling
Sometimes "select based on all layers" really means "select the shape of this stuff." Procreate has a different tool for that.
- Select layer content: Open Layer Options and tap Select, or hold two fingers on the layer. This creates a selection from what's drawn on that layer, based on the alpha channel. More opaque pixels produce a stronger selection.
- Combine selections from several layers: Run Select on one layer, then use the selection's Add mode with Automatic Selection or Freehand to build on it. This lets you assemble a selection from multiple pieces and then paint, feather, or clear inside it.
- Use it for shading and texture: Because the selection follows the layer's alpha, it's well suited to adding detail across multiple layers. Pair it with Alpha Lock on a target layer so you only paint where content already exists.
Procreate's own guidance is that the layer Select option isn't the right choice if you just want to move or copy a whole layer. For that, highlight the layer and use Transform.
Method 4: Multi-Select Layers for Moving and Grouping
If your real goal is to act on several layers together, you don't need a selection at all.
- Multi-select: Tap one layer, then swipe right on additional layers. They highlight in a darker blue. Swipe right again on a selected layer to deselect it.
- What you can do: Transform (move, scale, rotate), Liquify, group, and merge. Color-adjustment effects such as color balance or blur generally can't be applied to several layers at once, so group and flatten a copy, or apply the effect per layer.
- Group first for tidiness: Once layers are selected, tap Group at the top of the Layers panel. Groups are a clean way to organize line art, color, and shadow for each character.
Method 5: Find the Right Layer Quickly with Layer Select
A related headache is not knowing which layer holds the pixels you want. Layer Select solves this. Go to Actions > Prefs > Gesture Controls > Layer Select and assign a gesture, such as Touch or Modify Button + Touch. Then tap an object on the canvas to see the layer it sits on. If several layers overlap at that point, Procreate shows a panel for each, and you pick the one you want.
It doesn't make selection tools sample all layers, but it removes the guesswork of toggling layers on and off before you set up a Reference.
A Practical Workflow for Coloring Across Many Layers
Here's a repeatable routine for layered illustrations:
- Keep line art for each element on its own layer or group.
- Duplicate line layers, merge the duplicates into "Ref – Lines," hide it, and set it as Reference.
- Create flat-color layers beneath the lines and Color Drop into the regions.
- Use Alpha Lock or clipping masks on those color layers for shading and texture.
- When line art changes, delete the reference copy and rebuild it before further fills.
Name layers clearly. Reference layers are invisible, so it's easy to forget they exist and wonder why a fill is behaving oddly.
Troubleshooting
- Color Drop fills the whole layer: The Reference isn't active, or the layer you're sampling is empty. Check that the reference layer is set and that you're dropping onto the intended target layer.
- Selections ignore some lines: Those lines weren't in your merged copy. Rebuild the reference including them.
- Fills leak through small gaps: Close the gaps on the reference copy, or raise the threshold slightly.
- Edges look jagged or have halos: Use Selection feather, or fill slightly beyond the lines on a layer beneath them.
- Reference seems outdated: It is a snapshot. Any edit to the originals requires a fresh merged copy.
Handing Procreate Art Off to a Motion Pipeline
Many motion designers and animators use Procreate for boards, character designs, and styleframes, then move into After Effects, Nuke, or Blender. A few habits make that handoff easier:
- Keep elements on separate layers, since the layer structure is what lets you animate pieces in compositing. The merged reference layer is a coloring aid, so delete it, or keep it hidden and clearly named, before export.
- Group by element (head, arm, prop, background) so the layers are easy to interpret after export.
- Check that every layer carries alpha and that no hidden helper layers end up in your delivered files.
FAQ
Is there a setting to sample all layers in Procreate? No. Automatic Selection and Color Drop work from the active layer or one Reference layer.
Can I use multiple Reference layers at once? No. Merge duplicates into one layer and use that as the single Reference.
Will merging duplicates damage my original layers? No, as long as you merge only the copies. Keep the originals intact and hide the merged copy.
What if I only need to select content from several layers? Use Select from Layer Options (or the two-finger hold) on each layer and build the selection up with Add mode.
Can I edit multiple layers at the same time? Yes, for transforms, Liquify, grouping, and merging. Select them by swiping right in the Layers panel.