How to Subtract Selections in Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To subtract from a selection in Procreate, make your initial selection, switch to Freehand mode, draw a closed shape around the area you want to remove, and tap Remove in the bottom toolbar. The enclosed area is cut out of the active selection, and the diagonal mask lines update to show it. Rectangle and Ellipse modes often add the shape instead of subtracting it, so a reliable workaround is to invert the selection, draw the cutout shape, and invert back.
How Selection Subtraction Works in Procreate
Procreate has no modifier key like the Alt-to-subtract behavior in desktop apps. Subtraction is handled by two buttons in the selection toolbar, Add and Remove. Each shape you draw is a pending region, and the button you tap decides whether it joins the selection or is cut from it.
Once you know that, the odd behaviors make sense. Freehand mode treats Add and Remove as true boolean operations. The shape modes (Rectangle, Ellipse) and Automatic mode are less consistent, and users have reported that they commit the shape as an Add when you lift the stylus.
Step-by-Step: Subtract a Selection in Freehand Mode
This is the cleanest method and works for most cases.
- Open the Selection tool. Tap the S-shaped icon in the top toolbar. It turns blue when active.
- Choose Freehand from the mode options at the bottom of the screen.
- Draw your base selection. Trace around the shape and close it by returning to your starting point. The area outside is covered with diagonal mask lines, which mark what is protected.
- Tap Remove. The button sits in the bottom toolbar beside Add.
- Draw the area to subtract. Trace a closed shape over the part you want to cut away. It can overlap the edge of the existing selection or sit entirely inside it.
- Confirm the result. The enclosed region should now be masked out. If it looks wrong, undo and redraw.
This is how you would make a crescent moon: select a full circle, tap Remove, and draw a second, offset circle over it. What remains is the crescent.
Add and Remove can be chained
Procreate does not limit you to one pass. You can add a shape, subtract another, add a third, and subtract again. Each operation modifies the current selection, so complex silhouettes can be built from simple strokes. Tap undo or redo as needed. In polygon-style selecting, each undo steps back one tap.
The Unclosed-Shape Trick
In Freehand mode you can also subtract without closing your shape. Draw the outline, leave it open, and then tap Add or Remove. Procreate closes the path for you and applies whichever operation you chose.
This is useful when you want to cut away an area without precisely returning to the start point.
Subtracting with Rectangle and Ellipse Modes
This is where most frustration comes from. In some versions, Rectangle and Ellipse selections ignore the Remove state once you release the stylus and add the area anyway. The Remove button may even appear active while you draw and then grey out. Behavior can vary between Procreate releases and devices, so test on your own setup before assuming a method is broken.
If subtraction does not work for you in those modes, there are two dependable workarounds.
Workaround 1: Invert, cut, invert back
This is the simplest fix, and users have shared it as a workaround.
- Make your selection.
- Tap Invert. The mask flips, so the protected and selected areas swap.
- Draw your rectangle or ellipse over the area you want to exclude. Because you are working on the inverted selection, adding the shape is equivalent to subtracting it from the original.
- Tap Invert again to return to the original orientation, now with the shape removed.
It takes a few extra taps, but it sidesteps the Remove button entirely.
Workaround 2: Start inside the selection, then use Remove mid-stroke
This is a more fiddly option for Rectangle and Ellipse modes.
- Begin drawing the shape with your Pencil inside an already selected area.
- Without lifting, drag to the region you want to subtract.
- Tap Remove while still holding.
- Drag back to the starting area before releasing.
The final Add that fires on release only re-adds an area that was already selected, while the part you removed stays removed. It is awkward, but it keeps you in shape mode when you need precise geometric edges.
Constraining shapes
While drawing an Ellipse, holding a second finger on the screen constrains it to a circle. Users have reported that the same does not reliably produce a perfect square in Rectangle mode, so check your result when you need exact proportions.
Other Ways to Subtract Without the Remove Button
If the selection tools fight you, a few other routes get the same result.
Use Select Layer Contents
Open the layer's menu and choose Select (Select Layer Contents) to turn any painted pixels on a layer into a selection. This is helpful when your subtraction shape already exists as a drawing. Put the shape on its own layer, select its contents, and use the selection with Invert or Remove logic as needed. It also respects transparency, which helps with soft or feathered edges.
Reload your last selection
Tap and hold the Selection icon to reload your most recent selection and re-enter selection mode. From there you can add or subtract again. This saves you from rebuilding a complex selection after you accidentally cleared it.
Clear carefully
While in selection mode, tapping the clear (X) icon first removes any uncommitted dashed-outline selection. Tapping it again clears the mask completely. If you see the mask but no dashed line, one tap clears everything. Watch which state you are in before tapping.
Fill, then cut
If precision selection is not the real goal, you can fill a shape and then erase or cut away the part you do not want. It is not elegant, but for simple graphics, it is often faster than fighting a selection mode.
Troubleshooting Common Problems
- Remove is greyed out. This usually happens in Rectangle, Ellipse, or polygon-style modes after you release. Switch to Freehand, or use the invert workaround.
- The shape got added instead of subtracted. Undo, then try the unclosed Freehand trick or invert, cut, invert back.
- You can't tell what is selected. The mask opacity can be adjusted in the Actions menu under Prefs. Lowering or raising the selection mask visibility makes subtle edges easier to read.
- The selection disappeared. Tap and hold the Selection icon to reload the last one.
Where This Fits in a Motion Design Pipeline
Many motion designers and animators use Procreate for the parts of a project that benefit from a hand-drawn feel: style frames, character designs, cutout assets, textures, and matte shapes. Subtracting selections is a routine part of building those assets, especially when you need clean silhouettes or negative-space shapes you will later animate in After Effects.
A practical pattern is to build a clean, layered illustration in Procreate, export it, and then bring it into a motion tool. is one option for that second stage. A tool like that does not replace careful selection work in Procreate. When the edge of a shape really matters, a hand-built selection is still the more precise tool.
Quick Reference
Final Thoughts
Subtraction in Procreate is simple in Freehand mode and inconsistent in shape modes. Use Freehand with Remove as your default, and keep the invert, cut, invert back routine ready for geometric cutouts. If a version of the app behaves differently on your device, test on a throwaway layer before committing to a method on a client file.