How to Subtract Layers from Each Other in Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
Procreate has no single "subtract layer" command, but you can get the result three ways. Set the upper layer's blend mode to Subtract to remove its color values from the layers beneath. Tap a layer and choose Select to load its shape, then switch to another layer and Clear or Cut that area. Or use the selection tool's Remove mode. For a non-destructive version of the shape cut, use a layer mask.
Which Subtract Method Fits Your Job
"Subtract" means two different things in Procreate. One is color math, where pixel values are subtracted. The other is shape math, where one layer's alpha is cut out of another. Pick the method by the result you need.
Method 1: Use the Subtract Blend Mode
This is the closest match to subtracting one layer from another.
- Stack the layer you want to subtract above the layer you want to subtract from.
- Tap the N on the upper layer to open its blend options.
- Scroll through the blend modes and choose Subtract.
- Adjust opacity with the slider to control how much is removed.
The result is the lower layer's color values minus the upper layer's. Black areas on the upper layer subtract nothing, and brighter areas subtract more, pushing the underlying pixels toward black.
Subtract vs. Difference
Subtract goes dark and clips at zero, so the order of the layers matters. Difference returns the absolute difference between the two layers, so the order doesn't matter. Use Difference when you want to compare two versions of a drawing and see what changed. Where the two layers match, the result is black, and any mismatch shows up as brightness. Use Subtract when you want to take one layer's contribution out of another.
Some practical notes:
- Blend modes apply to everything below the layer in the stack, unless the layers are grouped. Put the layers you want to affect in a group to keep the subtraction contained.
- Heavy subtraction can degrade color or crush shadows. Do the math at the end rather than stacking several subtractions.
- If you only need the subtracted result, flatten a copy of the group and keep the original layers hidden.
Method 2: Subtract a Layer's Shape from Another Layer
When you want one layer's silhouette to punch a hole in another, load the shape as a selection.
- Tap the layer whose shape you want to use and choose Select. Procreate builds a selection from that layer's opaque pixels.
- Tap the layer you want to cut into.
- Choose Clear from the layer options, or tap Cut.
The shape is now removed from the target layer. Hide or delete the source layer and you're left with a precise cutout.
A few variations are worth knowing:
- Subtract the inverse (intersect). After loading the selection, tap Invert in the selection toolbar before clearing. This keeps only the overlapping area and removes everything else, which is effectively an intersect.
- Copy rather than cut. Select from the shape layer, move to the image layer, and use Copy & Paste from the selection toolbar. You get the cut-out piece on a new layer and the original stays untouched. This is a clean approach for fussy-cut collage work where you need to lift exact shapes from a photo layer.
- Position with transparency. If you're aligning a shape layer over a reference image, lower the reference layer's opacity so you can see both. Restore it to 100% when you're done.
This method is destructive, so duplicate the target layer before cutting. If you want to stay non-destructive, use a mask instead.
Method 3: Subtract with the Selection Tool
The selection tool has Add and Remove modes. With Freehand selection, you can draw a selection, then tap Remove and draw another loop to take that area out. That makes it handy for carving holes, such as a crescent moon from two overlapping circles.
Behavior with Rectangle and Ellipse modes has been inconsistent. Users have reported that these shapes automatically add to the selection when released, even with Remove active. If that happens in your version, try these approaches:
- Invert, cut, invert. Invert the selection, draw your cutout shape, then invert back. It's a longer path, but users report it as a workable fix.
- Use Freehand for subtraction. Draw the selection with Freehand, then tap Remove. Leaving the loop open also works in some cases to subtract along the path you draw.
- Draw the shape on its own layer. Build the subtraction shape as a filled layer, then use Method 2. This is more predictable and gives you precise, repositionable cutters.
Test the behavior in your current version of Procreate before depending on it in a deadline job. Selection tool behavior may differ between versions.
Method 4: Subtract Non-Destructively with Masks
A layer mask hides parts of a layer without deleting pixels, which is the right choice if the edit might change.
- Tap the target layer and choose Mask.
- Select the mask thumbnail so you're painting on the mask, not the layer.
- Paint with black to hide areas, or white to reveal them.
To use another layer's shape as the cutter, load it with Select, then paint or fill black on the mask inside the selection. The hole is now editable: paint white to restore it, or soften the edge with a blurred brush.
Clipping masks do the opposite job. A clipped layer is visible only where the layer below has pixels, which gives you intersection. Combine a clipping mask with a masked base layer for more complex shape logic.
Troubleshooting Common Problems
The Subtract blend mode makes everything black. The upper layer is probably too bright or opaque. Lower the opacity, or check that the subtraction layer contains only the values you want removed. White subtracts everything.
The cut leaves a soft or jagged edge. The selection was built from a layer with feathered or antialiased pixels. Check the source layer's edge before clearing.
The selection tool keeps adding instead of removing. See the Method 3 workarounds above, and consider building the cutter on its own layer.
Getting Procreate Subtractions into After Effects and Nuke
Procreate can share layers as bulk-exported individual images or multi-page PDF documents. For a motion pipeline:
- Export your layers as individual images if you want to keep masks and layers separate in your compositing app.
- For critical subtractions, flatten the finished result before it leaves the app. This avoids mismatches between Procreate's blend math and the compositing app's.
- Keep a version with the cutter layers visible and one without, so you can adjust in comp.
Hand-drawn art from Procreate often ends up as a style frame or a keyframe for a motion piece, so file prep matters. Name layers, use consistent canvas dimensions, and keep a copy of the pre-subtraction layers.
Where Styleframe Fits After the Procreate Work
Once your subtracted layers are cleaned up, you may want to turn a still into motion without redrawing every frame. is one option for that step.
Quick Reference
- Subtract colors: set the upper layer to Subtract. Use Difference to compare layers.
- Cut a shape: Select from the cutter layer, then Clear on the target layer.
- Keep only the overlap: Select, Invert, then Clear.
- Carve holes by hand: selection tool in Remove mode, or build cutters on their own layers.
- Stay editable: use a layer mask and paint the subtraction.
- Before export: flatten critical results for a safe handoff.
Procreate's tools are simpler than a compositor's, but with these four methods you can handle nearly any subtraction job. Choose color math or shape math by what you need, keep a duplicate before destructive cuts, and flatten the critical results before they leave the app.