How to Subtract from a Mask in Procreate
StyleFrame Team8 min read
To subtract from a Procreate layer mask, select the mask thumbnail (not the layer) and paint with black or use the Eraser. Anything painted black on the mask is hidden, and painting white brings it back. Gray values subtract partially, so a 50% gray gives you 50% opacity in that area. For precise shapes, make a selection first, then fill it with black on the mask.
How Procreate Masks Actually Work
A Procreate Layer Mask is a grayscale layer attached to a parent layer. White reveals the parent's pixels, black hides them, and every gray in between sets a proportional opacity. If you're used to After Effects, this is closer to a luma matte than to a Bezier mask path.
Two practical consequences follow:
- Subtracting is just hiding. Nothing is deleted from the parent layer. You can restore any subtracted area by painting white back onto the mask.
- Which layer is selected matters. With the mask selected, brush and Eraser strokes edit the mask. With the parent layer selected, the same strokes edit the artwork underneath the mask.
When a mask is your active layer, the Color Panel ignores hue, so you always paint in grayscale. If your strokes seem to do nothing, check that you're on the right layer first.
Method 1: Paint Black on the Mask
This is the most direct way to subtract.
- Tap the layer you want to mask, then choose Mask from the Layer Options menu. A white mask appears above it, so everything is visible.
- Tap the mask thumbnail to make it your active layer.
- Pick any brush and set the color to black.
- Paint over the areas you want to remove.
Use a soft brush for feathered edges and a hard brush for crisp cuts. Lower the brush opacity to build up subtraction gradually, which is useful for fades and gradients. If you overshoot, switch to white and paint the area back in.
Method 2: Use the Eraser on the Mask
With the mask active, the Eraser also subtracts. Erasing on a mask has the same effect as painting black, and it's often faster because you don't have to swap colors. The benefit of the Eraser is that it keeps your brush set separate from your mask edits, so you can paint white back with a brush and subtract with the Eraser without touching the color picker.
The distinction to remember: erasing on the parent layer destroys pixels, while erasing on the mask only hides them. If the edit needs to stay revisable, make sure the mask thumbnail is highlighted before you erase.
Method 3: Subtract with a Selection
Brushes are imprecise when you need a clean geometric cutout, such as a circle punched out of a shape. Selections give you exact edges.
- Select the mask layer.
- Use the Selection tool to outline the region you want to remove.
- Fill the selection with black. With a selection active, filling the layer (or dragging a black color into it) applies only inside the selected area.
- Deselect.
Because this happens on the mask, you can undo it later by filling the same region with white. If you need softer edges, apply a Gaussian blur to the mask afterward or feather the selection before filling.
Subtracting from a Selection Itself
A common point of confusion is that Procreate's selection tool has no true boolean subtract mode like the one in many vector tools. Users have asked for add, subtract, and intersect on selections. What you can do today:
Freehand mode
Draw a freehand selection and tap Add or Remove before closing it. To subtract from an existing selection, draw a loop inside the selected area and choose Remove. Unlike the Rectangle and Ellipse modes, Freehand supports this directly.
Rectangle and Ellipse modes
These behave less intuitively. When you release the pencil, the shape gets added to the selection, which is the opposite of what you want. A known workaround is:
- Start dragging the rectangle or ellipse from inside the existing selection.
- Move to the area you want to subtract.
- Tap Remove while still holding the shape.
- Drag back over your starting area before releasing, so the final add only re-adds already selected pixels.
It works, but it's fiddly. If you need to do this often, drawing a closed freehand loop and tapping Remove is usually faster, even if the shape is less perfect.
Fill then cut
Another dependable approach is to avoid selection arithmetic altogether. Fill the first shape on a layer, make a second selection, and clear it. For a crescent moon, fill a circle, select a smaller overlapping circle, and cut. Then use the result as a clipping base or mask source.
Method 4: Invert the Mask
Sometimes subtracting means flipping the whole logic: you've masked the thing you wanted to keep. Tap the mask thumbnail to open its options and look for the Invert command (the exact options vary slightly by version). Inverting swaps hidden and visible areas, so you can paint or select the small region you want to keep, then invert to subtract everything else.
When to Use Clipping Masks or Alpha Lock Instead
Layer masks aren't the only way to restrict where content shows, and sometimes another tool is the better fit.
- Clipping Mask: A layer clipped to the one below only shows where the base layer has pixels. To "subtract" from the result, erase or reshape the base layer. It's ideal for textures and shading you want to keep as separate, movable layers.
- Alpha Lock: Locks transparent pixels so you can only paint on existing content. It's quick for shading inside a silhouette, but it's destructive because painted pixels replace the originals. Prefer a clipping mask when you want to keep the shading adjustable.
- Layer Mask: Best when you need to hide and reveal freely, with partial opacity and fully reversible edits.
A solid habit is to use a layer mask whenever you aren't certain an edit is final, and reserve destructive erasing for work you've committed to.
Common Problems
Painting doesn't change anything. The parent layer is probably selected, or the color is mid-gray. Select the mask thumbnail and use pure black.
Edges look jagged. Use a softer brush, or select with feathering before filling the mask.
The wrong side is hidden. Remember that black hides and white reveals. If the result is backward, invert the mask or swap colors. Some tutorials describe this the other way around, so trust what you see on the canvas.
Mask moves independently of the artwork. Selecting a mask or its parent automatically selects the other as a secondary layer, which lets you transform both together. If they drift apart, reselect both before transforming.
How This Maps to After Effects, Nuke, and Blender
If you animate or composite, Procreate's approach is worth translating to your main tools, because the two models differ.
- After Effects: Masks are vector paths with a mode dropdown (Add, Subtract, Intersect, and others). Subtracting is a mode, not a paint stroke. A Procreate raster mask maps more closely to an alpha or luma track matte, so exporting a grayscale layer and using it as a matte reproduces the same behavior.
- Nuke: Roto and RotoPaint shapes combine with merge operations, and a "minus" or "stencil" style operation does the subtraction. Painted grayscale from Procreate can drive a matte input directly.
- Blender: Image-based masks can feed alpha or mix factors in the compositor or shader nodes, which suits hand-painted grayscale from an iPad.
When you export from Procreate, remember that a mask is baked into the flattened result. If you need the mask as a separate asset for a matte, export it deliberately: duplicate the layer, apply the mask on the copy, or fill the mask's visible area with white on a black background and save that as its own image.
Taking Procreate Art Into an Animation Pipeline
Masked Procreate illustrations often end up as source material for motion work: key art, style references, or layered elements. is an AI video and motion tool that fits at that stage, built for artists who want control rather than a one-click result. You drive each generation with reference images, video clips, and keyframes, so your hand-painted frames stay the authority.
A few places this is practical:
- Frames-to-Video: Use two or more Procreate keyframes as start and end points, and generate the motion between them while keeping your composition and linework in charge.
- Restyle and Ink-and-Paint: Use a painted frame as a style reference and apply that look to footage or other frames, so your illustration style carries through without redrawing every shot.
- Remove Background: If a subtracted mask didn't give you the clean cutout you wanted, a background removal pass can help produce usable alpha for compositing.
- 2D-to-3D and Turntable: Turn a character illustration into a rotating view for reference or layout.
- 4K Upscale: Bring finished frames up to production-ready 4K.
Quick Reference
Subtracting from a mask in Procreate comes down to knowing which layer you've selected and treating the mask as grayscale. Once that habit is set, the same thinking carries over to mattes and masks in After Effects, Nuke, and Blender.