How to Select Same Color in Canvas Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To select the same color in Procreate, open Selections, choose the Automatic tab, and tap the color you want. Drag your finger or Apple Pencil across the canvas to set the threshold, then switch to Add mode and tap each separate area of that color. If you only need to reuse a color rather than select its pixels, hold a finger on the canvas to sample it, then pick it again from Color History or the Value tab.
"Select same color" can mean two different jobs in Procreate, and the right tool depends on which one you have.
Two meanings of "select the same color"
Selecting pixels. You want a selection around every area that shares a color, so you can recolor, mask, delete, or copy them.
Matching a color. You want to paint with a color that already exists on the canvas, exactly, without eyeballing it.
Procreate handles these separately. Pixel selection lives in the Selections tool. Color matching lives in the Colors panel and the on-canvas color picker. Most of the confusion in tutorials comes from mixing them up.
Select areas of one color with Automatic Selection
Automatic Selection is the closest thing Procreate has to a magic wand. It selects a region based on the color you tap, within a tolerance you control.
- Select the layer that contains the color. Selecting from the wrong layer can give you an empty or unexpected result.
- Tap Selections in the top toolbar.
- Choose Automatic from the tabs at the bottom.
- Tap the color you want to select.
- Without lifting, drag left or right to adjust the selection threshold. A higher threshold pulls in more similar shades. A lower one stays strict.
- Lift to commit the selection.
The threshold is what makes this usable on real artwork. Flat vector-style fills need a very low value. Textured brushes, gradients, and soft edges need more, because pixels that look like one color to your eye are rarely identical in value.
Grab every patch of the same color
Automatic Selection picks up a contiguous area. If the same red appears in five separate places, one tap won't get all of them. Use Add mode:
- Make your first selection.
- Tap Add at the bottom of the Selections toolbar.
- Tap each additional area of the same color.
- Use Remove to subtract anything you picked up by mistake.
This is manual, and on busy artwork it can take a while. It's also the dependable approach, because you decide what counts as the same color rather than relying on a global rule.
Check the selection before you commit to an edit
Zoom in and look at edges before recoloring. If you see stray unselected pixels inside a shape, raise the threshold a little or tap them in Add mode. Fixing a selection takes seconds. Fixing a recolor with fringed edges takes much longer.
Recolor a selection as you select
Once you have the right selection, you don't have to fill it in a separate step. Procreate's Color Fill option fills each selection with your current color the moment you finish making it.
- In Selections, pick your method, such as Automatic.
- Tap Color Fill so it's highlighted.
- Choose your color from the Colors icon at the top right.
- Make the selection. The fill happens immediately.
Two caveats. Color Fill is remembered between sessions, so turn it off when you're done or you'll fill areas by accident later. It also works only on a single layer, not a layer group.
Faster alternatives to Selections for recoloring
If your real goal is changing one color to another, you may not need a selection at all.
ColorDrop with threshold
Drag the color dot from the top right onto the area you want to fill, and keep holding. Slide left or right to change how aggressively it fills. Tap Continue Filling to keep dropping color into other areas without dragging each time. It works like a paint bucket that you can drag out to fill an area.
Recolor from QuickMenu
Recolor is hidden by default. Enable QuickMenu in Actions → Prefs → Gesture Controls → QuickMenu, assign Recolor to one of the radial slots, then tap areas to fill. The Flood slider controls how aggressively it spreads. It's useful when you're swapping colors repeatedly, though it can affect more of the layer than you expect, so check the result.
Alpha Lock for a whole layer
When everything on a layer should change, such as lettering that needs to go from black to white, selection is overkill. Swipe right on the layer with two fingers to enable Alpha Lock, then fill or paint over it. Only the existing pixels accept the new color. You can also use the Adjustments menu (Hue, Saturation, Brightness, Color Balance, Curves) on that layer for a non-painted shift.
Pick the same color again
For the second meaning, matching a color, use the picker rather than a selection.
- Sample from the canvas. Touch and hold on the canvas to bring up the color picker loupe. Lift to set that color as your active one.
- Use Color History. The Color Panel keeps your last ten colors on the Disc, Classic, Harmony, and Value tabs. When you first open a new artwork it's empty, and each new color pushes out the oldest one. If you're about to sample something else, check History first.
- Use the Value tab for exactness. It shows numerical and hexadecimal values, which is the safest way to make a color match across layers or documents, or to transfer it into another application.
- Save it to a palette. If a color needs to survive the ten-color limit, add it to a palette. The active palette sits at the bottom of the Color Panel.
The reticle on the Disc is also handy: while you drag the smaller secondary reticle, it shows the color under it next to your most recent History color, so you can compare before committing.
Common problems and how to fix them
The selection leaves a halo. Anti-aliased edges contain blended pixels that fall outside a strict threshold. Raise the threshold slightly, or use Feather in the Selections toolbar to soften the transition. Test on a duplicate layer first.
Nothing selects, or the wrong thing does. Confirm you're on the right layer, since a color that exists only on a different layer may not register.
Similar shades get left behind. This is common on textured brushes. Increase the threshold, or accept that the art isn't truly a flat color and rebuild the fill on its own layer.
Color Fill is filling when you don't want it to. It's still enabled from an earlier session. Open Selections and turn it off.
Colors shift when you export. If a color looks different after you bring it into another app, use the hex value from the Value tab as your reference.
Taking Procreate color work into a motion pipeline
Selecting by color matters beyond illustration. Flat, cleanly separated color regions make better source material for animation: mattes, cel-style fills, style frames, and keyframes. A few habits help when the artwork is headed to After Effects or another compositing tool:
- Keep each major color region on its own layer where you can, so you rarely need color-based selection again downstream.
- Record key hex values from the Value tab in your project notes so a palette stays consistent across Procreate, After Effects, and Nuke.
- Export layered files (PSD) or individual PNGs, and inspect edges at 100% for fringing before importing.
Quick reference
Key takeaways
Procreate has no single "select all of this color everywhere" command. Automatic Selection with Add mode is the reliable route, and threshold is the setting that decides whether the result looks clean. For simple recoloring, ColorDrop and Alpha Lock often beat selecting at all. For color matching, use the on-canvas picker and the hex value in the Value tab. Organize layers by color from the start, and downstream work in After Effects or Nuke gets easier too.