How to Recreate the Stumpy Pencil Brush in Procreate
StyleFrame Team8 min read
To recreate the Stumpy Pencil brush in Procreate, duplicate a basic pencil or airbrush brush, replace its Shape Source with a flat, rough-edged chisel stamp, add a paper-like Grain Source, and tie size and opacity to Apple Pencil pressure and tilt. The original is a flat, soft, dark pencil that looks crudely knife-sharpened, so the chiseled tip and the grain matter most. You can also match the original author's own Procreate translation by tuning the same Brush Studio attributes by eye against sketches you draw with it.
What Makes the Stumpy Pencil Feel Like a Stumpy Pencil
The Stumpy Pencil began as a Photoshop brush by the artist behind the Stumpy Pencil blog. It imitates a flat, soft, dark pencil with a rough, hand-cut tip. The appeal is speed: it lays down a loose, effortless line that works for thinking on paper, and it has enough texture to blend into scanned pencil drawings.
Four traits define it, and each one maps to a Brush Studio setting:
- A chiseled, asymmetrical tip. This is the Shape Source.
- Visible paper tooth. This is the Grain Source.
- Easy darkness. This comes from rendering mode, opacity, and pressure response.
- A line that varies with hand angle. This comes from tilt and pressure dynamics.
If your brush gets these four right, it will feel like the original even if the numbers differ from anyone else's.
Start With the Author's Procreate Version or Build From Scratch
The original blog notes that its author translated the brush for Procreate on iPad and points to a separate post for details. If you can get that version, open it in Brush Studio and read through each attribute. That is the quickest way to see how the brush was constructed.
If you want to understand the brush or adapt it to your own drawing habits, build it yourself. A custom build also lets you tune the brush to your Apple Pencil, your pressure curve, and your canvas resolution. The steps below take that route.
Step 1: Duplicate a Base Brush
Never edit a stock brush directly. In the Brush Library, swipe left on a brush and tap Duplicate. A soft airbrush works as a base, and so does any pencil brush. Starting from a pencil gives you sensible pressure behavior to refine, while starting from an airbrush gives you a clean slate.
Tap the duplicate to open Brush Studio. You'll see the attribute list and a Drawing Pad, where you can test every change as you make it. Keep drawing on the pad throughout. Judging by feel and by sample strokes is more reliable than judging by slider values.
Step 2: Build the Chisel Shape
Open Shape and look at the Shape Source. You have two options.
Use the Source Library. Tap Edit, then Import, then Source Library. Pick a rough, organic shape rather than a clean circle. A dry-ink style shape is a workable starting point because its edges are irregular. Then flatten and elongate it by adjusting the shape settings.
Import your own stamp. This gives you the most faithful chisel:
- In any drawing app, make a flat rectangular or slightly slanted mark with uneven, rough edges, as if cut with a knife.
- Draw it in white on a solid black background and save it as a JPG. Procreate's brush engine reads white as opaque and black as transparent.
- Import it as the Shape Source. If the result looks inverted, tap the source with two fingers to invert it.
One common stumbling block: a PNG with a transparent background and a black design imports as a blank square, because black reads as transparent. A white design or a JPG with a solid background avoids this.
With the shape in place, check how it behaves as you rotate your hand. For a chisel, you want the orientation to follow the stroke or the pencil's azimuth rather than staying fixed. If the tip stays locked to the screen, the brush will feel like a stamp rather than a pencil. The Orient to iPad Screen option in General settings is useful for stamp-like behavior, so decide deliberately whether you want it on or off.
Step 3: Add the Paper Grain
Open Grain and choose a Grain Source. The Source Library has paper-like textures, or you can import a scan of your own paper. The grain sits inside the shape and gives the line its tooth.
Two choices matter here:
- Moving versus texturized grain. Moving grain drags the texture along with the stroke, which looks like a soft smudge. Texturized grain fixes the texture to the canvas, as paper behaves. For a pencil, texturized usually reads as more convincing.
- Scale and depth. If the grain is too coarse, the line looks like charcoal. If it's too subtle, you lose the stumpy character. Test at your normal working size, because grain scale changes with canvas dpi.
Zoom your canvas in and out while testing. A brush that looks right at 100% can look flat or noisy when you zoom out.
Step 4: Set Stroke Path and Stabilization
Open Stroke Path. Spacing controls how densely the shape is stamped along the line. Keep it low enough that the line looks continuous but high enough that the grain breaks up the stroke slightly. Too tight and the line turns solid and digital; too loose and you'll see the individual stamps.
Streamline and stabilization should stay low. The original is prized for its immediacy, and heavy smoothing makes a pencil feel like a vector tool. A little jitter can add a hand-drawn wobble, but too much makes it look fake. Keep the Taper settings minimal, since a flat pencil doesn't taper like a brush pen.
Step 5: Tie the Brush to Apple Pencil Pressure and Tilt
Open Apple Pencil settings. Procreate brushes can respond to pressure, tilt, and, with Apple Pencil Pro, squeeze and barrel roll. For this brush, aim for the following:
- Pressure to opacity, so light touches leave faint marks and firmer ones go dark. The original goes dark easily, so don't make the pressure curve too steep.
- Pressure to size, kept modest. A real stumpy pencil changes width more with angle than with pressure.
- Tilt to size or opacity, so laying the pencil on its side gives a broad, soft shading stroke, and holding it upright gives a tighter line.
If you can't reach full darkness without pressing hard, don't change the brush first. Adjust the App Pressure Sensitivity curve in Procreate's settings. The Apple Pencil's dynamic range is wide, and a lighter hand may never reach the top of it with the default curve. This is a global fix that benefits every brush.
Step 6: Tune Rendering and Dynamics
Check the Rendering attribute. For a dry medium, a glaze-style mode usually works better than a blending mode, which can feel wet. Test a few and watch how overlapping strokes build up. A pencil should darken progressively as you hatch over an area.
Then look at Properties for minimum and maximum size and opacity. Setting sensible limits keeps the brush predictable when you switch between sketching and detail work. Finally, open About this Brush to rename it, and set a preview stroke so you can find it quickly in the library.
Step 7: Make a Matching Eraser
The original set included a matching eraser that kept the textured quality of the line. You can do the same: duplicate your finished brush, then set it as an eraser (use the brush's Eraser tool and choose your custom brush for it). This keeps the grain in erased areas so corrections don't leave suspiciously clean edges.
Troubleshooting
- Brush paints a solid blob. Spacing is too tight, or the grain depth is too low.
- Shape or grain imports as blank. Check for a transparent PNG with a black design, and reimport it as a white-on-black JPG.
- The line looks too clean. Reduce stabilization, increase grain depth, and check that you haven't set a taper.
- Tip doesn't rotate with your hand. Review the shape's rotation and azimuth settings.
- Brush feels different at different canvas sizes. Grain and shape scale depend on canvas resolution, so retune on a canvas matching your usual working size.
Using the Brush in a Motion Pipeline
For motion designers, a good pencil brush is most useful for key poses, storyboards, animatics, and rough-animation passes. Draw at your final composition's aspect ratio, keep drawings on separate layers, and export as PNG or PSD so they open cleanly in After Effects, Photoshop, or Nuke.
Final Checklist
Before you call the brush done, run through these checks:
- The tip reads as flat and slightly rough when you rotate your hand.
- Texturized grain shows paper tooth without overwhelming the line.
- Hatching builds darkness gradually.
- Light and heavy pressure both give a usable range.
- Tilt produces a broader, softer shading stroke.
- A matching eraser preserves the texture.
Draw a page of thumbnails, hatching, and quick gestures before adjusting anything else. The Stumpy Pencil was always a tool for thinking quickly on paper, so the best test of your recreation is whether it stays out of your way.