How to Make Black and White Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To make an image black and white in Procreate, select the layer, open Adjustments, choose Hue, Saturation, Brightness, and drag the Saturation slider all the way left. For a more controlled result, duplicate the layer, put a white layer between the two, and set the top duplicate to the Luminosity blend mode. To check values without changing the artwork, add a mid-grey layer on top set to the Saturation blend mode, which you can toggle on and off.
Each method makes a different trade-off between speed, tonal accuracy, and non-destructive editing. The sections below cover when to use each one and how to hand the result to a motion pipeline.
Method 1: Desaturate with Hue, Saturation, Brightness
This is the fastest route and the one most tutorials start with.
- Select the layer you want to convert.
- Tap the Adjustments icon and choose Hue, Saturation, Brightness.
- Drag the Saturation slider fully to the left.
Be aware that this adjustment is destructive on the layer's pixels. Duplicate the layer first, or work on a flattened copy, if you might want the color version back.
Why the values look different afterward
A common surprise is that a saturated color can land at a different grey than you expected. Users on Procreate's own forum noticed this with a mid-orange (hex #ea8b5b) that collapsed to a grey around #a2a2a2, noticeably darker than it looked in color. The forum thread left the cause unresolved, but the practical effect is that tonal separation can change once the color is gone.
If a grayscale result feels flat or muddy, this is a likely reason, and it's the reason to look at the next two methods.
Method 2: Fix contrast with Curves
Straight desaturation often leaves an image looking dull. Curves is the standard follow-up.
- Go back to Adjustments and choose Curves.
- Select Gamma.
- Move the bottom-left node to deepen the darks, the top-right node to lift the highlights, and drag the middle of the line to shift midtones.
Small moves go a long way. Pull the shadows in slightly and add a gentle S-curve, and most converted images regain depth. If you want a harsh, graphic look, such as a notan-style study with only two or three values, push the curve steeply so the midtones collapse toward black and white. Judge the result by whether the subject is still readable. A value study that doesn't read as the subject isn't doing its job.
Method 3: The Luminosity blend method
Some artists prefer a luminance-based conversion over plain desaturation because it can preserve a more natural tonal relationship between colors. One long-running forum tutorial calls this "Luminance" and sets it against Desaturation and Grayscale as the three main approaches. Whether it's the best is a matter of taste, so test it against your own image.
Here's the setup in Procreate:
- Insert or open your image.
- Duplicate the layer.
- Add a new layer, fill it with white, and move it between the original and the duplicate.
- Select the top duplicate, tap its N, and set the blend mode to Luminosity (it sits in the same group as Hue, Saturation, and Color).
The white layer in the middle blocks the color from the original, so the Luminosity layer contributes only brightness. You end up with a grayscale image built from three layers that you can group and toggle.
To get a single flat image from this stack, use Actions > Add > Copy Canvas and paste it as a new layer. The catch is that you'd need to repeat the copy step after changing the underlying artwork.
In the forum comparison, this method returned the same grey for the orange test color as the other approaches, so don't expect a dramatic difference on every image.
Method 4: A toggle layer for checking values
Often you don't want a black and white deliverable. You want to see whether your painting or design holds up in grayscale while you work. A toggleable layer is the cleanest way to do that.
- Create a new layer at the top of the stack.
- Fill it with a mid-grey (50% grey from the Values tab or the Disc picker works).
- Set the layer blend mode to Saturation. Hue and Color are worth trying too, though Saturation is a common choice.
Everything underneath now reads in grayscale, and your artwork is untouched. Switch the layer's visibility on and off as you paint. If you use this constantly, put it in a layer group to keep things tidy.
This approach has the same caveat as desaturation. The values you see are the values Procreate computes from the blend, so use it as a quick check rather than a calibrated measurement.
Method 5: System-wide grayscale on iPad
Procreate has no built-in grayscale preview for the Reference window, and users have asked for one. Procreate's team said they would look into it, so check current release notes before assuming it's still missing. In the meantime, iPadOS has a workaround that works in any app:
- Open Settings > Accessibility > Accessibility Shortcut.
- Select Color Filters.
- Make sure Color Filters is set to Grayscale.
- Triple-click the top button to toggle grayscale on and off.
This shows the whole screen, including your reference photos, in grayscale. The downside is that it affects the entire display and doesn't let you see color and grayscale side by side. Remember to triple-click again to return to color. If your screen seems stuck in grayscale, turning the shortcut off in Settings will also restore it.
Which method to use
Taking Procreate grayscale into a motion pipeline
If your Procreate work is heading into After Effects, Premiere Pro, or Nuke, a few habits save time:
- Keep your layers intact. Export in a way that preserves your layers for compositing. Export your color version as well as the grayscale version so you can decide later.
- Keep the conversion out of Procreate if you need flexibility. Because the Hue, Saturation, Brightness adjustment changes the layer itself, it can make sense for animation work to import the color art and do the black and white conversion in your compositor, where you can tweak it per shot.
- Export at your delivery resolution. Upscaling a small canvas later softens line work, so set the canvas size up front.
- Treat Procreate's grayscale as a look, not a master. If the artwork will be graded, keep it in a format with enough tonal information for the grade.
Quick troubleshooting
- The image looks flat after desaturating. Add a Curves adjustment and increase contrast, or try the Luminosity method.
- Colors that looked distinct now look the same grey. Different colors can end up as similar greys. Adjust the original color values, or use Curves to separate them.
- I need the color version back. Duplicate before converting, or use the toggle-layer method so nothing is changed.
- The iPad stays grayscale. Triple-click the top button or switch off Color Filters in Accessibility settings.
Summary
For a quick conversion, drop the Saturation slider to zero, then refine with Curves. For better tonal control, use the Luminosity blend stack. For checking values while you work, keep a mid-grey Saturation layer at the top and toggle it. Whichever you choose, keep a color copy, and if the artwork is going into a motion project, consider doing the final black and white treatment in your compositor where it stays editable.