How to Erase One Layer Within Another Layer in Procreate
StyleFrame Team6 min read
To erase one layer's shape out of another layer in Procreate, select the contents of the shape layer, switch to the layer you want to cut into, and clear the selection. Touch and hold the shape layer with two fingers to select its pixels, tap the target layer, then use Clear from the Layer Options menu, a three-finger scrub, or Cut. The eraser only affects the active layer, so a selection is how you carry one layer's outline over to another.
Why the eraser can't cut through layers
Procreate edits only the selected (primary) layer. If you erase on a color-fill layer, the line art above it stays untouched, and vice versa. This is intentional. It keeps every layer independent, which is the main advantage of working in layers.
The consequence is that "erase layer A where layer B is" can't be done with a brush. You need a selection that remembers B's shape, then apply it to A. Photoshop users do something similar by selecting line work on one layer and deleting that shape from another layer. Procreate does it through its selection system.
Step by step: knock out one layer using another layer's shape
This is the core workflow, for example removing the area under line work from a flat color layer so nothing overlaps for a screenprint or a separated cutout.
- Open the Layers panel and find the layer whose shape you want to use as the cutter (the line art, a silhouette, a logo).
- Select its contents. Touch and hold the layer with two fingers. Alternatively, tap the layer once to select it, tap it again to open Layer Options, and choose Select. Moving diagonal lines will appear over everything outside the selection.
- Tap the target layer (the one you want to cut a hole in) so it turns blue. The selection stays active when you change layers.
- Remove the selected area using any of these:
- Tap the layer again and choose Clear from Layer Options.
- Scrub back and forth over the canvas with three fingers.
- Choose Cut from the selection's contextual menu.
- Paint over the selection with the Eraser.
- Deselect once you're done.
Hide the cutter layer afterward to check the result. The hole in the target layer should match the cutter's outline exactly.
How selection accuracy works
Layer selection is based on the layer's alpha channel. The more opaque the pixels, the more fully they're selected. A solid shape produces a clean cut. Soft brushes, semi-transparent strokes, or anti-aliased edges produce partial selections, which means partial erasure along the edges.
If you want a harder cut, increase the opacity of the cutter content or fill the shape solid on a duplicate layer. Select from that duplicate instead of your original art.
Choosing the right removal method
The forum answer for this problem lists several ways to delete the selected area. They behave differently enough to matter.
Be careful with Clear. With no active selection, it wipes the entire layer. It leaves the name, blend mode, and opacity intact, which can make an accidental clear look like a blend mode problem. If something vanishes, undo immediately.
A non-destructive alternative: masks
Clearing pixels is permanent once you've moved on from undo history. If you expect revisions, consider a mask on the target layer instead. Mask is among the functions in the Layer Options menu.
Duplicating the target layer and hiding the copy is a simple way to preserve your work, and it's worth doing before any destructive edit.
For a restricted effect rather than a hole, such as shading that must stay inside a shape, use Alpha Lock rather than erasing. Alpha Lock stops painting on transparent areas of a layer, so strokes can only affect pixels that already exist. It restricts painting rather than erasing, but it solves a lot of "stay inside the lines" problems without any cutting.
Erasing across multiple layers at once
A second common request is removing one object that is split across several layers, such as decking drawn on four layers, without visiting each one.
- Make a selection that covers everything you want gone.
- Swipe right on additional layers in the Layers panel to add them as secondary layers. They're highlighted in blue, while your primary layer stays bright blue.
- Choose Transform and drag the selection fully off the canvas. Commit the transform.
Selection and transform actions apply across all selected layers. Cut and Copy only apply to the primary layer, and you can't use Adjustments with several layers selected. That is why the off-canvas Transform trick is the reliable bulk-delete method. It also lets you see what's about to be removed before you commit.
If the layers are already grouped, selecting the group as primary lets you apply Selection and Transform actions to all layers inside it. Paint, smudge, erase, and Adjustments don't apply across a group.
Troubleshooting common problems
Nothing was erased. You probably had the cutter layer active when you cleared, or the selection was lost before you cleared. Reselect, then confirm the target layer is highlighted before clearing.
The wrong layer got cut. The primary layer is the one that receives edits. Check which layer is bright blue before you act.
Edges look ragged or leave a halo. The cutter has semi-transparent edges. Use a harder-edged version of the shape, or expand the cut by selecting from a slightly larger duplicate.
Drawing appears behind color. This is layer order, not erasing. A layer higher in the stack covers everything below it. Drag the line layer above the color layer.
You can't find Select. Tap the layer once to select it, then tap it again to open Layer Options. The two-finger hold gesture is the shortcut.
Taking cutouts and knockouts into a motion pipeline
For motion designers, Procreate is often where a styleframe, character, or texture begins before it moves into After Effects, Nuke, or Blender. Knockout layers can matter here because overlapping fills may create visible double-density areas once you animate, blend, or composite, and clean separation keeps your layers usable for parallax and rigging. Keep your cutter layers, name them clearly, and keep your original art so you can adjust after the animatic.
Quick reference
- Cut one layer's shape from another: two-finger hold on the cutter, tap the target, Clear.
- Delete an object split across layers: select it, swipe right to add layers, Transform off-canvas, commit.
- Safety net: duplicate and hide the target layer before cutting.
Once the selection habit is in place, most overlap problems reduce to the same three moves: select, switch layers, remove.