How to Do the Black and White Challenge on Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To do the black and white challenge on Procreate, switch your iPad to grayscale (Settings > Accessibility > Display & Text Size > Color Filters > Grayscale), paint your whole piece without seeing any color, then turn the filter off to reveal the result. If you only want to check values inside the app, add a top layer filled with 50% gray and set its blend mode to Saturation. You can toggle that layer on and off as often as you like without touching your artwork.
What the Black and White Challenge Actually Is
The challenge, also called the "no color challenge," went around TikTok and YouTube. You pick colors by instinct or by a rough plan, draw while the screen shows only shades of gray, and then switch color back on at the end. The picture either lands as a harmonious piece or as a chaotic rainbow, but the values should hold either way. If you got the lights and darks right, the image still reads.
The exercise is useful because color hides value mistakes. Without color to lean on, you notice weak contrast, muddy midtones, and places where you were hoping hue would do the work of light. Illustrators use it to train their eye. For motion designers, colorists, and compositors, the lesson transfers directly to lighting, grading, and look development.
What You Need
- An iPad with Procreate installed.
- An Apple Pencil or a similar pressure-sensitive stylus is recommended, since shading and blending depend on it.
- A reference image. Some creators desaturate their reference and add a little contrast before starting, so the reference matches what they see on the canvas.
- A rough palette plan, or none at all. Some artists lay out a bank of swatches first. Others pick colors blind.
Method 1: System-Wide Grayscale (The "True" Challenge)
This is the version most people mean. It uses an iPadOS accessibility setting, so it affects the whole screen, including Procreate's color wheel and your reference.
- Open Settings on your iPad.
- Go to Accessibility, then Display & Text Size.
- Scroll down to Color Filters and turn it on.
- Choose Grayscale.
Everything on screen is now monochrome, so you can't judge hue while you paint. That's the point of the challenge.
Set Up a Triple-Click Shortcut
Toggling the filter through Settings every time is tedious. You can bind it to a button instead:
- Open Settings > Accessibility.
- Scroll to Accessibility Shortcut.
- Select Color Filters.
Now triple-clicking the power button switches grayscale on, and triple-clicking again switches it off. If you find yourself stuck in grayscale with no obvious way out, this is the fix: triple-click again, or turn off Color Filters in Settings.
This approach also works in every app, so you can check values in a photo viewer, a reference board, or a browser, not just Procreate.
Method 2: A Non-Destructive Gray Check Inside Procreate
If you want to check values without changing system settings, build a gray-check layer:
- Create a new layer at the very top of your layer stack.
- Fill it with 50% gray. The quickest way is the Values tab in the color popover, or you can snap the picker on the Disc view to the neutral center.
- Set the layer's blend mode to Saturation. Hue and Color are worth testing too, but Saturation is the usual choice.
- Toggle the layer's visibility to flip between color and grayscale.
This leaves your artwork untouched. Put the layer in a group if you like to keep things tidy. The tradeoff for the challenge is that Procreate's color wheel and swatches still show their real colors, so you will see the hues you pick. Consider it a lighter, self-policed version.
A related trick for a reference image: place a layer filled with black above it and set it to a Saturation-style blend, which grays out the reference without editing the original.
Method 3: Convert a Color Image to Grayscale with Luminosity
Sometimes you need a proper grayscale reference or a flattened gray version of a finished painting:
- Duplicate the color layer.
- Add a new layer and fill it with white.
- Drag the white layer between the original and the duplicate.
- Select the top duplicate, tap its N icon, and choose Luminosity.
- Pinch the three layers together to merge them.
If you want a flat single-layer version of your canvas to work from, go to Actions > Add > Copy Canvas, then paste it into a new layer.
Running the Challenge Step by Step
- Prepare the reference. Desaturate the photo, bump the contrast slightly, and import it via Actions > Add > Insert a Photo.
- Turn on grayscale. Use the system filter (Method 1).
- Sketch first. A simple line sketch gives you something to build on. Some people find their usual process falls apart a bit without color, so don't worry if you work out of order.
- Block in values. Lay down big shapes of dark, mid, and light. A flat brush works well for a painterly look.
- Choose colors by value, not hue. Treat the color wheel as a brightness selector. If the skin needs to be a midtone, pick something that looks like a midtone. You don't have to use realistic colors. Some artists go deliberately for a rainbow effect and let correct values make the image read.
- Push contrast. Check your darkest and lightest areas. Some artists discover they were underusing dark values, especially in crevices like where a neck meets hair.
- Render and refine. Smooth and blend as usual, but go easy on the smudge tool if you want to avoid muddy colors at the end.
- Reveal. Triple-click to turn color back on and compare.
Common Pitfalls
Grayscale conversions don't preserve what you expect. When you desaturate a saturated color, the resulting gray can look darker than the original did. In one Procreate forum test, a vivid orange (#ea8b5b) converted to roughly #a2a2a2, and several methods (Saturation slider, Saturation blend layer, Luminosity layer) produced similar values. If a color feels brighter than it looks in gray, trust the gray. That's the whole point of the check.
Stuck in grayscale. If the filter won't switch off, triple-click the shortcut button or disable Color Filters in Settings.
Forgetting to compare. Take a screenshot in grayscale before you reveal the color. The before and after comparison is what makes the exercise worth sharing.
Overthinking the color reveal. The result may look odd. That's normal. The goal is a strong grayscale image first, and a pleasing color version second.
Variations Worth Trying
- Grayscale first, color later. Paint fully in gray, then add color on top using blend modes. Many illustrators use this workflow, and it keeps your values intact.
- Selective color. Keep a grayscale layer on top of the original color image, then erase or cut areas to let color show through, such as a single colored background.
- Time limits. Give yourself 30 minutes to force simpler value decisions.
- Limited palettes. Pick five swatches before turning on grayscale, then try to make them work.
Why This Matters for Motion and VFX Work
Value-first thinking is not just an illustration habit. It carries over to compositing, color grading, and look development, where checking luminance is a common habit. If you've ever had a frame fall apart after a grade, the cause may have been a value problem hiding behind color.
Doing the challenge on a single still frame is a quick way to build that reflex. A style frame that holds up in grayscale is more likely to survive the pipeline: color management, compression, and different displays.
Quick FAQ
Does the challenge require a specific Procreate version? Probably not. The system grayscale filter is part of iPadOS, not Procreate, so it works in any version. The in-app blend-mode methods have also been reported to work in earlier Procreate versions.
Can I turn a grayscale image back into color in Procreate? Not with a single command. You can keep the original color image underneath and erase or cut parts of the grayscale layer, or you can paint color over gray using blend modes.
Is there a grayscale toggle in Procreate's Reference window? Users have requested one, and Procreate's team has said they would look into it, but for now the accessibility shortcut or a Saturation layer are the workarounds.
What's the fastest way to check values mid-painting? The triple-click shortcut. It takes a second and works with any reference you have open.