How to Do Grayscale Challenge on Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
The grayscale challenge in Procreate is not a built-in feature. It is a workflow: you paint a piece entirely in values (black, white, and grays), then add color on top using layer blend modes. To run it, sketch your subject, block in a gray silhouette, refine a two-value notan, paint the full grayscale, then add a new layer set to Color and paint your palette over it. Check your values at any point with a mid-gray layer set to Saturation, or with the iPad's system Color Filters.
What the grayscale challenge actually is
The name covers a few slightly different exercises, so pick the one you mean:
- Grayscale-to-color painting: you finish a monochrome painting, then colorize it. This is a common version and the one this guide focuses on.
- Value check: you temporarily view a colored painting in grayscale to test whether the values read.
- System grayscale filter: you switch the whole iPad display to gray so you cannot lean on color while you work.
All three build the same habit: judging light and dark separately from hue. For motion designers, that habit pays off quickly. A styleframe that holds up in grayscale will usually survive grading, compression, and a client's uncalibrated monitor.
Why separate value from color
Painting has three components: value (how light or dark), color (the hue), and chroma (how gray or vibrant). Simple, familiar subjects let you handle all three at once. Complex or unfamiliar ones are easier if you split the process: drawing first, then values, then color and chroma together.
Working in grayscale first forces you to solve form, lighting, and composition without hue covering up weak decisions. When you add color afterward, you are adjusting a structure that already works.
Step 1: Set up the canvas
- Create a new canvas in an RGB color profile. Do this deliberately. If your canvas ends up in a gray profile, Procreate will not let you paint in color later (more in the troubleshooting section).
- Import a reference if you have one. In Actions, open Canvas and turn on Reference. You can use it for both values now and color sampling later.
- Sketch on its own layer. Settle proportions, perspective, and composition here, because you want these problems solved before you start shading.
- Fill a layer below the sketch with a mid-gray so you are not judging values against pure white.
Step 2: Block in the mass
Create a new layer above the sketch and, using any gray and any brush, paint one flat shape that covers the whole subject. This silhouette is your first read. If the shape does not communicate what you are drawing, fix the silhouette before you go further.
Step 3: Build a notan
A notan is a two-value study: just dark and light. Squint at it. If it does not look like anything, the design is not working yet, and no amount of rendering will rescue it. Spend real time here. Adjust where the darks cluster, where the lights open up, and how the shapes connect.
Once the notan reads clearly, expand it into a full grayscale painting. Add midtones, soften transitions where form turns, and sharpen edges where you want focus. Keep the number of values manageable. Fewer, well-placed values usually beat a muddy range.
Step 4: Check values with a non-destructive grayscale layer
You will want to verify values as you go, ideally without altering your painting. The Procreate community's recommended approach:
- Add a new layer at the very top of the stack.
- Fill it with 50% gray. You can get this from the Values tab in the color popover, or by snapping the reticule to the center of the Disc color picker.
- Set the layer's blend mode to Saturation. Hue and Color are also worth testing to see how they differ.
- Toggle the layer on and off whenever you want to check.
There is one caveat. Users have reported that desaturating this way, or with the Saturation slider in Hue, Saturation, Brightness, can shift how bright certain colors appear. A saturated orange, for example, can come out darker than expected. Treat any single method as a guide rather than ground truth, and if a value matters, compare two methods.
A second method uses a duplicate of your artwork placed at the top, a white layer between the duplicate and the painting, and the duplicate set to Luminosity. That works as a grayscale checker too, though you will need to redo Copy Canvas (Actions > Add > Copy Canvas) after new work if you want a flattened version.
The system-level option
For a stricter challenge, you can filter the whole display. On iPad, go to Settings, then Accessibility, then Display & Text Size, then Color Filters, and choose grayscale. Everything on the screen, including Procreate's interface, goes gray. Remember to switch it off before judging colors.
Step 5: Colorize the grayscale painting
When the grayscale holds up, move to color. This approach keeps your values intact.
Build a palette first
If you have a reference, sample the most representative colors from it and save them in a new palette. A small, deliberate palette keeps the final image cohesive.
Add a Color layer
- Create a new layer above the grayscale painting.
- Set its blend mode to Color.
- Paint with a soft brush, such as the default soft airbrush, and treat it like painting from scratch. Blend, mix, and match your palette to the form.
Because the layer only supplies hue and chroma, the grayscale beneath controls the light and dark.
Add depth with Multiply and Overlay
Many artists stop after the Color layer, but two more layers can push the result:
- A Multiply layer above it, where you paint over the dark areas to deepen shadows and add depth.
- An Overlay layer above that, where you paint bright color over the highlights so high points stand out.
Look for the breakthrough
Most paintings hit a stage where something feels wrong: proportions, color relationships, values, or the overall design. Expect it. Step back, identify the single biggest problem, and fix that rather than adding detail everywhere. That final correction is often what makes the piece work.
Troubleshooting: color stuck in grayscale
If you cannot pick any color after the challenge, check these in order:
- Hard reboot the iPad. Closing background apps and restarting the device fixed the issue for several users.
- Check the canvas color profile. Open the Actions menu, then Canvas, then Canvas Information, then Color Profile. If it shows a gray profile such as Generic Gray Gamma 2.2, that is the cause.
- Make a new RGB canvas. From the Gallery, tap +, then the small custom canvas icon, choose Color Profile, and pick an RGB option.
- Move your art over. Three-finger swipe down to copy a layer, open the new RGB canvas, and three-finger swipe down again to paste.
- Check what you imported. Some users traced the problem to a downloaded paper texture whose profile carried over into the canvas.
- Check for a layer mask. If you are on a Layer Mask, grayscale-only painting is expected. A mask hides or shows its parent layer, and it works in grays.
Taking the exercise into a motion pipeline
The grayscale challenge is useful beyond illustration. If you design styleframes or look-dev boards for animation, a value-first pass tells you early whether a frame has a readable focal point, enough separation between foreground and background, and a lighting plan you can actually build in 3D or comp.
A practical way to use it:
- Do the grayscale pass in Procreate and export it as a flattened image.
- Use it as a lighting and value reference in After Effects, Cinema 4D, or Blender, and compare your renders against it with a Luminosity or desaturated view.
- Keep the colorized version as a separate layer set so you can swap palettes without touching the values.
If you want to push these frames into motion, you could explore tools such as . No tool replaces the painting skill the challenge builds. It can give you a way to extend a strong still into motion while keeping your decisions in charge.
A quick checklist
- Start in an RGB canvas so color is available later.
- Sketch, then block a gray silhouette.
- Refine a notan until the subject is obvious.
- Paint the full grayscale and verify values with a Saturation-mode gray layer.
- Build a palette from your reference.
- Colorize on a Color-mode layer, then add Multiply and Overlay layers.
- Solve the one biggest problem before finishing.
Run the challenge a few times with different subjects. The more often you separate value from color, the faster you will judge both, and the more reliably your frames will translate from Procreate into the rest of your pipeline.