How to Color Selections in Procreate 4.2
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To color a selection in Procreate 4.2, tap the Selection tool (the S icon in the top bar) and choose Automatic, Freehand, Rectangle, or Ellipse to outline the area. Then tap another tool to commit the selection, and drag the color from the top-right Color circle into the selected area (ColorDrop). You can also paint inside it with any brush, since nothing outside the selection will change. For recoloring existing pixels instead of filling new ones, use the Adjustments menu (Hue, Saturation, Brightness) while the selection is active.
Before You Start: How Selections Behave in Procreate 4.2
A selection in Procreate limits edits to a defined region of the active layer. While the selection is committed, you'll see diagonal lines moving across the area outside it. That area is protected, so brushes, erasers, smudges, fills, and adjustments only affect pixels inside.
Two habits prevent most mistakes:
- Selections apply to the active layer only. If you color and nothing seems to happen, check which layer is highlighted.
- A selection stays active until you cancel it. Tap the Selection tool again to deselect. Forgetting this is the most common reason a brush "stops working" outside an area.
If the diagonal mask is hard to read, open Actions > Prefs and adjust the selection mask visibility slider. This is useful on busy illustrations, where the default shading blends in.
Step 1: Make the Selection
Pick the mode that matches the shape you're isolating.
Automatic
Tap an area and Procreate selects pixels of similar color. Keep your finger down after tapping and drag left or right to change the threshold: lower values stay tight to the tapped color, higher values spread into neighboring tones. Keep tapping to add more areas. This mode is best for flat, clean-edged artwork such as vector-style shapes or inked line work with solid fills.
Freehand
Trace around the region with a stylus or finger. Tap point to point for straight edges, or drag for curves. Closing the loop creates the selection. It's the best option for organic shapes like hair, cloth, or hand-drawn character parts, and it works well to clean up an Automatic selection that grabbed too much or too little.
Rectangle and Ellipse
Drag across the canvas for geometric selections. These suit backgrounds, panels, UI-style elements, or quick gradient bands.
Add, Remove, and Invert
The selection toolbar lets you build complex shapes. Use Add to include more area, Remove to subtract, and Invert to flip the selection so you can color everything except the chosen part. A practical trick: select a subject once, invert, and fill or adjust the background without touching the subject.
Selecting All Painted Pixels on a Layer
To select everything painted on a layer, open the Layers panel, tap the layer, tap it again to open its options, and choose Select. This grabs all non-transparent pixels, which is the fastest base for recoloring an entire element.
Step 2: Choose Your Color
Tap the color circle in the top right to open the Colors panel. Use whichever tab fits your task:
- Disc for quick, intuitive picking.
- Classic for Hue/Saturation/Brightness sliders.
- Harmony for complementary and analogous suggestions based on your current color.
- Value for exact numeric or hexadecimal input, which matters when you need to match a brand or style-guide color.
- Palettes for saved swatch sets.
The Color History (the last ten colors you used) is handy for returning to a shade you just tried. If you work from a brief with fixed colors, import or build a palette first so every selection fill draws from the same swatches.
Step 3: Apply Color to the Selection
There are several ways to do this, and each gives a different result.
Method A: ColorDrop
Drag from the top-right color circle and release inside the selected area. The selection fills with your current color. Hold your finger or stylus on the canvas after dropping and slide to adjust the ColorDrop threshold, which controls how aggressively the fill flows into similar neighboring pixels. With a selection active, the fill stays inside the selection boundary, so you get a clean edge.
This is the quickest way to flat-color shapes, but it replaces pixels, so use it on a dedicated layer if you may need to change your mind.
Method B: Paint Inside the Selection
With the selection committed, pick any brush and paint across the area. Strokes are clipped to the selection, so you can scribble loosely without worrying about edges. This is ideal for adding shading, texture, or gradients while keeping the silhouette intact. Switch colors with the eyedropper to sample from your artwork as you go.
Method C: Recolor Existing Pixels with Adjustments
When the shape already has color and you want to shift it rather than overwrite it:
- Make the selection.
- Open the Adjustments menu.
- Choose Hue, Saturation, Brightness.
- Slide to adjust. The change applies only to the selection.
This keeps your shading and texture intact while changing the underlying color, which is usually what you want when recoloring a character's jacket or a prop.
Method D: Alpha Lock After Selecting
If you only need to recolor what's already painted on a layer, Alpha Lock on the layer is often faster than a selection. Combine them: use Select to grab a region, then paint within it on an alpha-locked layer for precise control.
Step 4: Refine Edges and Avoid Common Problems
Jagged or hard edges. If a fill looks harsh, undo it and use Feather in the selection toolbar before coloring, which softens the boundary. For flat-color work, leave it off for a crisp edge.
White halos around filled shapes. Anti-aliased edges leave semi-transparent pixels that a ColorDrop at a low threshold can miss. Raise the ColorDrop threshold slightly, or use Alpha Lock plus a fill.
Color bleeding into the wrong area. This usually means the Automatic threshold was too high, or your line art has gaps. Lower the threshold, close gaps in the line work, or use Freehand to correct.
Nothing happens when you paint. Check that you're on the layer you intended and that your brush opacity isn't zero. Also confirm the selection is where you expect by looking at the diagonal mask.
Edits you can't reverse. Put colors on new layers above your line art, and use a clipping mask when you want color confined to the shape beneath. That way you can change opacity, blend mode, or hue later without redoing selections.
A Non-Destructive Workflow for Production Art
For work that will end up in a motion pipeline, treat selections as a way to build layered assets rather than final flat images:
- Draw line work on its own layer.
- Create a color layer below it and use Automatic selection on the line layer to fill shapes.
- Add shading on separate layers clipped to the base colors.
- Name your layers by element (skin, jacket, background) so they're easy to find later.
Export layers or flattened frames depending on what your pipeline needs. Layered files give you more flexibility to adjust shapes and colors separately and keep your compositing flexible.
Taking Procreate Selections Further in a Motion Workflow
Procreate is excellent for painting style frames, character designs, and texture studies, but it doesn't animate in the way After Effects or Nuke does. The question is how to bring those stills into a moving pipeline without losing the look you painted.
A reasonable approach is to finalize colors in Procreate, export clean keyframes, build motion from them in your animation or motion tool of choice, then bring the sequence into your compositing software for grading and finishing.
Quick Reference
Once you internalize the sequence of select, commit, choose color, and apply, coloring selections becomes fast. Pair it with layer discipline and the results carry cleanly into whatever animation or compositing tool comes next.