How to Color Eyes in Procreate Cartoon
StyleFrame Team8 min read
To color cartoon eyes in Procreate, build the eye on separate layers: a white sclera layer, an iris layer clipped to it, then pupil, shadow, and highlight layers clipped above. Fill the iris with a mid-tone, add a darker top gradient where the upper lid casts shadow, place a dark pupil, and finish with one or two crisp white highlights. Keeping each element on its own layer lets you recolor quickly and export a layered PSD for rigging in After Effects.
Set Up the Canvas and Layers First
Most tutorials treat eye coloring as a one-off illustration. If you are animating the character afterward, the layer structure matters as much as the colors.
Start with a canvas large enough to scale up in your comp. Working at 4000 × 4000 px or similar gives you room to crop and punch in without softness. Then create these layers, ideally named from the start:
- Line art (top, so it never gets buried)
- Highlights
- Shadow
- Pupil
- Iris
- Sclera
- Skin or background (bottom)
Layer naming is tedious in Procreate, but it pays off. A file full of "Layer 14" becomes a headache once it lands in After Effects, especially if you plan to puppet-pin or parent the pupils to a null.
Keep your sketch on its own layer at reduced opacity. Draw the lids and eye shape cleanly first, because the colors will be clipped to that shape.
Step 1: Fill the Sclera
Cartoon eyes rarely use pure white straight from the palette. Pick a very light, slightly tinted value, such as a warm off-white for a friendly character or a cool pale gray-blue for a more sinister one.
- Select the sclera layer beneath your line art.
- Draw or ColorDrop the fill inside the eye outline. Drag the color from the top-right swatch into the closed shape, then adjust the fill threshold if it leaks.
- Turn on Alpha Lock or use this layer as the base for clipping masks above it.
If the eye is large and round, as in classic rubber-hose or modern TV animation styles, the sclera might be nearly the full shape. For smaller, anime-influenced cartoon eyes, the visible sclera may be a thin sliver on each side.
Step 2: Block In the Iris
Create a new layer above the sclera and set it as a Clipping Mask. This keeps anything you paint from spilling outside the eye shape.
Draw a circle for the iris. Hold the line at the end of your stroke to snap to a clean shape, then tap Edit Shape if needed. Fill it with your base iris color.
Some practical rules for cartoon eyes:
- Let the upper lid crop the iris. A fully visible iris reads as surprise or fear. Slightly covering the top reads as relaxed or neutral.
- Pick a saturated base, then work darker and lighter around it. Cartoon eyes tolerate more saturation than realistic ones, and the iris is often the strongest color on the face.
- Keep the value distinct from the skin and hair. Eyes should hold up even when the color is desaturated. Toggle a grayscale preview, or add a temporary Color adjustment layer, to check.
Step 3: Add Gradient and Depth to the Iris
A flat disc works for some styles, but most cartoon eyes benefit from a simple gradient.
- Create a new clipping layer above the iris.
- Choose a darker version of your base color (shift the hue slightly toward blue or purple rather than just adding black).
- Paint a band across the top of the iris with a soft airbrush.
- On another clipped layer, add a lighter, more saturated tone to the bottom third. This simulates light bouncing inside the eye.
For a stylized look, try the layer blend modes. Set the lighter bottom layer to Add or Color Dodge at low opacity for a glow, or set the darker top layer to Multiply for a cleaner shadow. Experiment, and keep each effect on its own layer so you can dial it back later.
If you want a radial texture, use the Smudge tool with a hard brush and pull short strokes outward from the pupil. That is a quick way to suggest iris fibers without drawing each one. For flatter cel-style characters, skip this and use two or three hard-edged tone shapes instead.
Step 4: Place the Pupil
Add a new clipped layer above the iris and paint the pupil in a near-black. Use a deep blue-black or brown-black instead of pure black, so it sits in the palette.
Pupil size affects emotion more than most artists expect:
- Small pupils feel sharp, alert, or suspicious.
- Large pupils feel soft, cute, or startled.
Because pupils often get animated for eye tracking or emotional beats, keep them on a separate layer from the iris. In After Effects, you can then move or scale the pupil independently, or constrain its motion inside a mask matching the iris.
Step 5: Add Lid Shadow
The upper eyelid should cast a shadow across the top of the eyeball. This one detail makes a flat cartoon eye feel like it sits inside a head.
- Create a layer above the iris and pupil, clipped to the sclera.
- Set the blend mode to Multiply.
- Paint a soft shadow along the upper edge of the eye using a muted, cool tone such as a desaturated purple or blue-gray.
- Lower the opacity until it reads as subtle.
If your character is lit from one side, shift the shadow slightly in that direction. A consistent light direction across both eyes sells the form better than any other trick.
Step 6: Place Highlights
Highlights make the eye look wet and alive. They also tell the viewer where the light source is.
- Use a hard round brush at full opacity.
- Place one primary highlight, usually a circle or rounded shape, on the same side in both eyes.
- Add a smaller secondary highlight on the opposite side if the style calls for it.
- Keep highlights mostly in the iris or overlapping the iris and pupil edge.
A quick tip: if both eyes are the same shape, copy the highlight layer, but adjust the position slightly rather than mirroring it exactly. Perfect symmetry looks mechanical, and a tiny offset helps the face feel natural. Procreate's Drawing Guide with Symmetry is useful for building the original shape, but turn it off for the final pass.
Step 7: Finish With Line Art and Color Holds
Review the line art layer last. Some cartoon styles use black linework around the whole eye. Others use colored lines, where the lash line is darker than the lower lid. Try setting the line layer to Multiply or locking the alpha and filling it with a dark brown or deep purple for a softer look.
Finally, check these before moving on:
- Do the eyes read at the size they will appear on screen? Zoom out to thumbnail size.
- Do both eyes agree with each other in light direction?
- Does the color hold up against the character's skin tone and background?
Coloring Choices for Different Cartoon Styles
Choose your approach based on how the character will move. Intricate gradients can flicker or crawl if you redraw them frame by frame. Simpler tone shapes are easier to keep consistent.
Preparing Procreate Eyes for After Effects
If the artwork is headed to motion, prep it deliberately:
- Export as PSD to preserve layers. Clipping masks usually translate, but check the result in After Effects, and flatten or merge anything that behaves differently.
- Draw extra states: half-closed, closed, and blink frames, plus alternate pupil sizes if the character will emote.
- Keep the sclera, iris, pupil, highlight, and lids separate so you can parent, track, or animate each independently.
- Avoid effects that don't survive export, such as certain Procreate-only liquify or blur adjustments. Apply them destructively on a duplicate layer, or recreate them in After Effects.
Quick Troubleshooting
- Colors look muddy: You are probably darkening with black. Shift hue and saturation instead.
- Eyes look flat: Add the lid shadow and a gradient in the iris.
- Eyes look cross-eyed or lifeless: Check pupil placement and make sure both highlights fall on the same side.
- Paint spills outside the eye: Use clipping masks or Alpha Lock rather than painting directly on the base layer.
Final Thoughts
Coloring cartoon eyes in Procreate is mostly a layering exercise: base, iris, pupil, shadow, highlight, line. Get the structure right, choose a consistent light direction, and keep each element separate. The result is an eye that looks good as a static illustration and is ready to animate when it moves into After Effects or the rest of your pipeline.