How to Change the Colordrop Threshold in Procreate
StyleFrame Team6 min read
To change the ColorDrop Threshold in Procreate, drag your active color from the top-right dot into a shape and keep your finger or Apple Pencil on the screen after the fill floods in. Pause until a blue Threshold bar appears along the top of the canvas, then slide left to fill less or right to fill more. Lift when the fill looks right, and Procreate remembers that percentage for your next ColorDrop.
What the ColorDrop Threshold Actually Does
ColorDrop is Procreate's bucket-style fill. You drag a color into an area and it floods outward until it hits an edge. The Threshold controls how far that flood spreads before it stops, which matters most when your linework has soft edges, anti-aliased pixels, or textured strokes.
- Threshold too high: the fill leaks past your outlines and covers the whole layer, or most of it.
- Threshold too low: the fill stops early, leaving a halo of unfilled pixels along the edges or only a small patch of the shape.
Many "ColorDrop is broken" complaints come down to a Threshold set to the wrong value. The setting persists between fills, so a value you dialed in for one drawing can misbehave on the next.
Step-by-Step: Adjusting the Threshold
- Select your color. The active color shows in the dot at the top right of the canvas.
- Drag the dot into your shape. Release nothing yet. Keep your finger or Pencil down as the color floods in.
- Hold still. After a moment, a thin blue bar appears across the top of the canvas with a percentage reading.
- Slide left or right. Move left to lower the percentage and fill less area. Move right to raise it and fill more. You don't need to touch the bar itself, and you can slide anywhere on the screen.
- Lift to commit. The fill is applied at the percentage you stopped on.
A few practical notes:
- Use one finger or just the Pencil. Switching between the two, or trying to steady the bar with a second hand, breaks the continuous contact the gesture needs.
- Small adjustments matter. For clean line art, low percentages often work well, and you'll tend to find a value that suits your style and stick with it.
- Because Procreate remembers the last value, check the bar every time you start a new piece. If a fill suddenly behaves differently than it did yesterday, the stored threshold is the first thing to suspect.
Make Sure the Shape Can Actually Hold a Fill
Before you tune the percentage, check the artwork. ColorDrop reads the pixels on the layer it's filling, so a few conditions have to be true:
- Closed shapes. If there's a gap in your outline, even a tiny one, the color escapes. Zoom in and close it with a brush.
- The right layer. By default, the line art has to be on the same layer you're filling. If you drop color on an empty layer, there are no edges to stop it, so it fills the entire layer regardless of threshold.
- Alpha Lock. If ColorDrop seems not to be working, check that Alpha Lock isn't on.
Fill on a Separate Layer with a Reference Layer
Keeping line art and color on separate layers is the standard approach for anything you'll revise or hand off. Procreate supports it through the Reference feature:
- Open the Layers panel.
- Tap the thumbnail of your line art layer to open Layer Options.
- Tap Reference.
- Select a new, empty layer beneath the line art and use ColorDrop there.
Now ColorDrop measures edges from the Reference layer while painting onto the layer you've selected. The Threshold gesture works the same way. You'll often use a slightly different value than you would when filling on the line art layer itself, so re-check the blue bar.
Automatic Selection is another option for filling on a layer other than your line art layer.
Troubleshooting: When the Slider Won't Move
If the blue bar never appears, or it appears and refuses to move, work through these in order:
- Confirm you're using ColorDrop. It's triggered by dragging from the color dot. The Selection tool (S icon) and the Recolor adjustment (wand icon) behave differently and have their own controls.
- Keep contact unbroken. Lifting even briefly after the flood ends the gesture. Drag in, hold, then slide, in one motion.
- Wait for the bar. It needs a short hold to appear. If you start sliding immediately, it may not register.
- Check free storage. Procreate's team has suggested that having under roughly 10% of your iPad's storage free can cause odd behavior. It may not be your cause, but it's quick to rule out.
- Restart Procreate or the iPad. Users have reported the slider sticking at 0% or 100%, including after updates, and some cases resolved on their own or were acknowledged as bugs. Updating to the latest version is worthwhile.
- Try a clean test. Draw a closed circle on a fresh canvas and try the gesture there. If it works, the problem is in your original file's layers or line art. If it doesn't, the issue is the app or the device.
Limits to Know About
ColorDrop is intentionally simple. Some artists coming from dedicated inking and flatting software find it limited:
- Users note there's no dedicated gap-closing setting, so open lines leak unless you close them manually.
- Some users find that anti-aliased edges make crisp inking and flatting harder.
- For large flatting jobs with many tiny regions, selections and clipping masks may be faster than repeated ColorDrop passes.
None of this makes ColorDrop unusable. It just means line quality matters more than any slider setting.
Where This Fits in a Motion and VFX Pipeline
Motion designers, animators, and compositors may not live in Procreate, but it can show up in a pipeline: rough storyboards, hand-drawn textures, character flats, matte paintings, and style frames on an iPad before the work moves into After Effects, Photoshop, Cinema 4D, Blender, or Nuke. A few habits make that handoff cleaner:
- Keep fills on separate layers. Using the Reference method means your color flats and line art stay independent, which makes them easy to treat as separate elements in After Effects.
- Export layered files. Keep your layers intact when you export so you can bring them into After Effects or Photoshop without flattening them first.
- Use consistent thresholds across a set. If you're flatting a series of frames or character poses, settle on one threshold early so edge quality is uniform across the set.
- Check edges at the comp resolution. A fringe that's invisible on an iPad screen can show up once the art is scaled in a 4K comp.
Quick Reference
Final Thoughts
The ColorDrop Threshold is one gesture: drag, hold, slide, lift. Many problems come from breaking contact too early, filling on a layer with no edges to read, or forgetting that the last-used value is still active. Pair it with the Reference layer feature for clean separation of line art and color. That makes the artwork much easier to carry into the rest of your motion pipeline, whether you're compositing in After Effects or Nuke.