How to Black and White Scale in Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To convert an image to black and white in Procreate, select the layer, open Adjustments (the magic wand icon), choose Hue, Saturation, Brightness, and drag Saturation fully to the left. If you want to keep the original intact, put a mid-grey layer on top set to the Color or Saturation blend mode, or duplicate the layer and set the top copy to Luminosity above a white fill. Afterward, use Curves to rebuild contrast, since removing color often flattens the image.
Method 1: Desaturate with Hue, Saturation, Brightness
This is the fastest route and the one most tutorials start with.
- Select the layer you want to convert. A flattened or merged image is the simplest case.
- Tap the Adjustments icon (magic wand) and choose Hue, Saturation, Brightness.
- Drag the Saturation slider all the way left. The color drains out and leaves a grayscale image.
- Lift your finger or pen to commit the change.
The change is destructive. It bakes into the pixels of that layer, so duplicate it first if you might want the color back. The methods below are the usual workarounds.
Method 2: A non-destructive preview layer
If you only want to check your values while painting, don't alter the artwork at all.
- Add a new layer at the top of the stack.
- Fill it with a mid-grey. You can get 50% grey from the Values tab in the color panel, or by snapping the picker on the Disc.
- Set that layer's blend mode to Color (or Saturation).
Everything beneath appears desaturated, and you can toggle the layer on and off to compare against full color. Your painting stays untouched. This is the better habit for illustrators and concept artists who check values constantly, and it suits storyboard or style-frame work where you flip between value and color passes.
One thing worth knowing: this gives you the same result as dragging the Saturation slider. Both approaches shift the apparent values of your colors, and neither is a "pure" value read.
Method 3: Duplicate, white layer, Luminosity
This layered approach takes more steps but gives you a stack you can regroup, reorder, or turn off.
- Open the Layers panel and duplicate your image layer.
- Add a new empty layer and fill it with white (drag white from the color panel onto the layer).
- Drag the white layer between the original and the duplicate.
- Tap the "N" next to the top layer and set its blend mode to Luminosity, found near the bottom of the list.
- To get a single grayscale layer, pinch the three layers together to merge them.
Luminosity keeps the brightness information of the top layer and discards its hue and saturation. With white beneath it, you get a clean grayscale rendering. If you prefer to keep things reversible, group the three layers instead of merging, then toggle the group. When you paint on the original later, you'll need to refresh the duplicate, because it is a copy and won't update.
For a single flattened version of everything without merging your working layers, use Actions > Add > Copy Canvas.
Why your grays don't match your expectations
A common surprise: you desaturate a bright orange and the result looks darker than you expected. Users report this with the Saturation slider and the blend-mode methods alike. As a worked example, an orange around RGB 234, 139, 91 lands on a mid-light grey of roughly 162.
Practical consequences:
- Colors with similar perceived brightness merge in grayscale. A red and a green that look distinct in color can become nearly the same grey. That is useful information when you're checking whether a composition reads without hue.
- The saturation slider and the Luminosity method agree closely, so don't expect one to fix the other's output.
- If you want control over the result, you need a different approach than simple desaturation, such as Curves, covered next.
Fine-tune contrast with Curves
Straight desaturation often produces flat, muddy grays. Fix it with a curve:
- Go to Adjustments > Curves.
- Choose Gamma.
- Drag the bottom-left point to the right to deepen the shadows.
- Drag the top-right point left to push the highlights brighter.
- Move the line between the two points to adjust the midtones.
Make small moves. A gentle S-curve usually adds the punch you need without crushing detail.
Add a splash of color back
Because grayscale conversion discards color, you can't just undo it later after merging. To keep a region in color:
- Keep the original color layer underneath and put the grayscale version on top.
- Select the area you want colored using Selection in Automatic mode, or paint it with the Eraser tool.
- Cut or erase that area on the grayscale layer, revealing the color below.
Both the selection-and-cut approach and the Eraser give the same result. The eraser is better for soft transitions with a soft-edged brush, while selection suits crisp shapes. Keep the color original on its own layer so you can revisit the mask.
Use black and white as a working step in your painting
Grayscale isn't only for finished images. Many painters build in stages: sketch, then values, then color. A black and white study (sometimes called a notan when reduced to two values) tells you quickly whether the composition reads. If a two-value or grayscale version is unreadable, color won't rescue it.
A common way to carry this into color is to paint the values on a grayscale layer, then place a color layer above it set to a blend mode such as Color and paint or fill over it. The grayscale underlayer keeps your lighting and form intact while you explore palettes.
Exporting for After Effects, Premiere, and other tools
If your Procreate work is heading into a motion pipeline, a few habits save trouble:
- Export PSD to keep layers, so you can bring your grayscale value pass, color layers, and line art into After Effects as separate elements. Check blend modes after import, since some modes may not map one to one in other software.
- Export PNG for flattened frames or stills with transparency.
- Watch the color profile. Your canvas profile can differ from your composition's working space. Set up color management in After Effects or Premiere deliberately instead of trusting the preview.
- Name layers clearly before export. A "values_gray" layer is far easier to rebuild in a comp than "Layer 14".
- Work at a resolution you can scale from. Plan the final output size before you paint.
A grayscale pass is also useful beyond illustration: as a luma matte, a displacement or depth map for a 2.5D move in After Effects, a roughness or bump texture in Cinema 4D or Blender, or a value reference for lighting a shot. Keeping it as a clean, separate layer pays off in every one of those cases.
Where Styleframe fits after the Procreate pass
Once you have a black and white frame, value study, or inked drawing, you may want to take it further without redrawing every frame. A grayscale or line-based Procreate frame can serve as a reference image for AI video and motion tools.
These tools don't replace your compositing workflow. You keep your Procreate artwork and your comp, and add controlled motion in between.
Quick reference
Common mistakes to avoid
- Desaturating a layer you can't recover. Duplicate or keep a color copy first.
- Applying the adjustment to the wrong layer. Check which layer is selected, so a stray selection doesn't leave parts of your piece in color.
- Judging values by saturation alone. Check the grayscale result, not the colored one, before deciding the lighting works.
- Skipping contrast. A pure desaturation is a starting point, not a finished black and white image.
- Flattening too early. Merge only when you're sure, or keep a layered backup before exporting.
Procreate's black and white tools are simple, but they reward a little care. Pick the method that matches whether you need a permanent conversion, a values check, or a layered, reversible setup, and carry the result into your motion pipeline as a separate, clearly named pass.