How to Black and White in Procreate
StyleFrame Team6 min read
To make an image black and white in Procreate, select the layer, open Adjustments, choose Hue, Saturation, Brightness, and drag Saturation all the way to the left. For a non-destructive version, put a mid-grey fill layer on top and set its blend mode to Saturation or Color. For a more tonally accurate conversion, duplicate the layer, put a white layer between the two, and set the top duplicate to Luminosity. Which one you pick depends on whether you want speed, reversibility, or control over how colors translate to grey.
Method 1: Desaturate with Hue, Saturation, Brightness
This is the fastest route and the one most tutorials start with.
- Select the layer you want to convert in the Layers panel.
- Open the Adjustments menu.
- Choose Hue, Saturation, Brightness.
- In the menu at the bottom of the screen, drag the Saturation slider fully to the left.
The color is gone and you have a grayscale image. The catch is that this edit is destructive to that layer's pixels. If you plan to go back to color, duplicate the layer first or use one of the non-destructive methods below.
Fix flat contrast with Curves
A straight desaturation often looks dull, because colors that contrasted by hue can land on similar greys. Go back to Adjustments and choose Curves, then work in the Gamma channel:
- Drag the bottom-left node right to deepen the shadows.
- Drag the top-right node left to lift the highlights.
- Pull the midpoint of the curve to shift mid-tones lighter or darker.
Treat this as a judgment call per image. A portrait, a flat vector illustration, and a textured painting will each want a different curve.
Method 2: A non-destructive grayscale check layer
Many painters want to look at values without committing to a conversion. A top-of-stack layer does that cleanly:
- Add a new layer at the very top of the stack.
- Fill it with 50% grey. You can get this from the Values tab in the color popover, or by snapping the reticule on the Disc picker to the grey center.
- Set the layer's blend mode to Saturation (or try Color or Hue and compare).
- Toggle the layer's visibility to flip between color and black and white.
Nothing underneath changes, so you can leave this layer in your file as a permanent value check and hide it before export.
Why the greys might not match what you expected
A common complaint among Procreate users is that desaturating an image seems to change its values. A saturated orange can look noticeably darker once it becomes grey. In one forum test, an orange sampled at roughly RGB 234, 139, 91 turned into a grey around 162, 162, 162, and the poster reported that it did not seem to matter whether the fill layer was lighter or darker.
That is not a bug so much as a property of how hue and brightness interact. Our eyes perceive different hues as different lightness levels, and a simple saturation drop does not always reproduce the tonal relationships you see in color. If your values matter, as they do in a painting, a storyboard frame, or a matte, you need a conversion that respects luminance.
Method 3: Luminosity blend conversion
This approach is less well known but often gives a more natural grayscale. It uses two extra layers and a blend mode:
- Import or open your image.
- Duplicate the layer.
- Add a new layer, fill it with white, and move it between the original and the duplicate.
- Select the top duplicate and set its blend mode to Luminosity.
The result is a grayscale rendition built from the luminance of the image. In the forum test, this version produced the same grey for that orange as the saturation methods, so do not expect dramatic differences on every image. It is worth comparing on photos and paintings with a wide range of hues, where the differences are more visible.
To get a single flat layer from this stack, use Actions > Add > Copy Canvas and paste it as a new layer. Remember that the copy is a snapshot. If you paint more underneath, redo the step.
Group the duplicate and the white layer so you can switch the whole conversion on and off with one tap.
Method 4: Make a value study (notan)
If "black and white" for you means a stripped-down tonal study rather than a grayscale photo, the workflow is different. Painters often block in a notan, a simple black and white study of just two values, before introducing color:
- Fill a layer with a mid-grey under your sketch.
- On a new layer, paint the dominant shape of the subject in a single value.
- Add a second layer for the darkest masses.
- Check that the subject still reads when you squint at it.
If the shapes are not recognizable in black and white, the composition will not be rescued by color later. Once the values work, you can add color on layers set to blend modes such as Color or Multiply on top of the grayscale foundation.
Troubleshooting: Procreate is stuck in grayscale
Sometimes the problem is the opposite: you want color but the picker keeps returning grey. Common causes and fixes from the community:
- Restart the iPad. A hard reboot has resolved it for some users.
- Check the canvas color profile. Open the Wrench menu, then Canvas, then Canvas Information, then Color Profile. If it reads a grey profile such as Generic Gray Gamma 2.2, the canvas is grayscale-only.
- Copy to a new canvas. Copy the layer, create a new canvas with an RGB color profile (in the Gallery, tap + then the custom canvas icon, then choose Colour Profile and the RGB tab), and paste. Grayscale source images, such as a downloaded paper texture, are a frequent culprit.
- Check whether you are on a layer mask. Layer masks only show greyscale by design.
Exporting black and white work for motion pipelines
If your Procreate stills are heading to After Effects, Premiere Pro, Nuke, or Blender, a few habits save headaches:
- Export as PNG for flat frames or PSD if you want to keep layers, including your conversion layers, for adjustment in the compositor.
- Keep the original color version. A grayscale conversion cannot be reliably turned back into color, so duplicate before flattening.
- Decide where the final tonal tweaks live. Doing contrast adjustments in After Effects with Curves or Levels on an adjustment layer is more flexible than baking them in on the iPad.
- Remember that a grayscale-looking image may still be an RGB file. That is fine for most pipelines, and it makes toning or tinting later simple.
Which method should you use?
Practical tips
- Always duplicate or use a toggleable layer before converting, so you can recover color.
- Compare methods on your own images. Differences are subtle on some pieces and obvious on others.
- Adjust contrast after conversion, not before, since the grey values you get decide how much punch you need.
- Keep a grayscale check layer in long projects, and hide it before export.
- Leave final grading to your compositing app when the work is headed for motion.
With these methods you can go from a quick desaturation to a considered luminance conversion without leaving Procreate, and carry the result into the rest of your pipeline.