How to Adjust Threshold in Procreate
StyleFrame Team7 min read
To adjust the threshold in Procreate, drag your active color from the top-right corner into a closed shape, but keep your finger or Apple Pencil on the screen after the color floods in. Wait for the thin blue Threshold bar to appear above the canvas, then slide left to fill less area or right to fill more. Lift your finger to commit the fill. Procreate remembers the last threshold you used, so the next ColorDrop starts from that value.
Step-by-step: adjusting ColorDrop threshold
ColorDrop is Procreate's bucket-fill tool, and its threshold decides how far the fill spreads before it stops. Here is the full sequence:
- Select the layer you want to fill. By default, the shape you are filling needs to be on the same layer as the fill, unless you use a Reference layer or Automatic Selection (both covered below).
- Drag the color dot from the top-right corner of the canvas into the area you want to fill.
- Don't lift. Keep your finger or Pencil on the screen once the color has flooded in.
- Wait for the blue bar. A thin blue slider appears along the top of the canvas with a percentage reading.
- Slide left or right. Moving left lowers the threshold and fills less. Moving right raises it and fills more. You don't need to touch the bar itself, and your finger can be anywhere on the canvas.
- Lift to commit. The fill is applied at the value you stopped on.
The most common mistake is breaking contact. If you lift, or switch from Pencil to finger mid-gesture, the adjustment ends. Use one input only, from drag to release.
What the threshold actually controls
Think of the threshold as a tolerance for how different a neighboring pixel can be from the pixel you dropped on before the fill stops spreading.
- Low threshold: the fill is strict. It covers only pixels very close to the one you dropped on. On soft or anti-aliased line art, this often leaves a light halo of unfilled pixels along the edges.
- High threshold: the fill is permissive. It spreads across more pixels, which closes those edge halos but can leak through lines and flood the entire canvas.
For crisp, closed line art, a mid-to-high threshold usually works. For textured or anti-aliased edges, raise it a little at a time until the halo disappears, and stop before the fill escapes the shape.
Troubleshooting: when the slider won't cooperate
Procreate's own support threads show a handful of recurring problems. Work through them in order.
The whole canvas floods
Your shape probably isn't closed. A gap in the outline can let the fill escape. Zoom in on the line art and close the gap with a brush, or lower the threshold so the fill is less eager to cross faint edges.
Nothing fills, or the fill is tiny
The threshold is probably too low, or you are dropping onto a layer that has no outline on it. Raise the threshold, and check that you are on the layer containing the line art (or that a Reference layer is set).
The blue bar never appears
This almost always means the gesture was interrupted. Try it again with a single input and without lifting:
- Drag the color into the shape.
- Hold still until the fill appears and the blue bar shows up.
- Then slide horizontally.
If you are holding the color with the Pencil and swiping with a finger, that two-handed approach can break the continuous contact the gesture needs. Pick one.
The slider is stuck at 0% or 100%
A few things to rule out:
- Wrong tool. Confirm you are using ColorDrop, not the Selection tool (the S icon) or Recolor in Adjustments. Each behaves differently.
- Low storage. Procreate's support team has suggested that having under 10% of your iPad's storage free can sometimes make the app behave strangely. Check you have a healthy margin.
- Restart the app. Force-quit and reopen it before anything more drastic.
- Update Procreate. One user reported the slider stuck at 0.0% after an update and then recovering on its own, and Procreate staff said it might be related to a bug they were looking into. If it started right after an update, check for a newer version.
Reinstalling is a last resort. Back up your work first, since artwork lives inside the app unless you've exported or synced it.
The fill behaves differently from last time
This is the remembered-setting behavior. Procreate keeps your last threshold, so if you pushed it to 100% for one fill, the next fill starts there too. Adjust it again at the start of each new fill.
Filling on a separate layer with a Reference layer
Keeping flats on their own layer under your line art is cleaner and easier to revise. To do that with ColorDrop:
- Open the Layers panel.
- Tap the thumbnail of your line art layer to open its options.
- Tap Reference.
- Select a new, empty layer beneath the line art and ColorDrop into it.
The fill now reads its boundaries from the Reference layer but writes color to the active layer. The threshold gesture works the same way. This is a structure many artists prefer: line art on top, flats below, each independently editable.
Another option: Automatic Selection
Procreate's Selection tool also has an Automatic mode, which is another way to fill a shape that isn't on the layer you're filling.
This is useful when you want a selection rather than an immediate fill. If ColorDrop leaves rough edges, selecting first and then filling is often more controllable.
Practical settings for line art and animation work
A few habits make threshold adjustments faster and more consistent:
- Close gaps first. Fixing a gap in the line art takes seconds, and it saves repeated threshold fiddling.
- Fill on a layer below the line art. Use the Reference layer method so you can change colors without touching your linework.
- Re-check the threshold each session. Because the last value persists, make a quick adjustment part of starting a new fill.
- Zoom in on edges. Judge halos at 100% or higher. A fill that looks fine zoomed out may leave a fringe once the artwork is composited.
- Keep flats slightly generous. A fill that sits just under the line art, rather than stopping exactly at its edge, hides edge fringing when layers are flattened or composited.
If you are drawing frames for animation, consistent threshold settings across frames help keep flats from flickering in size or coverage, so it's worth fixing the value early and checking it frame to frame.
Where Styleframe fits in a Procreate-to-After Effects pipeline
Threshold adjustments are a hand-drawn, frame-level technique: you decide exactly where each fill stops. That precision is what you want for key art, character flats, and stylized frames. The harder question for many motion teams is what happens afterward, when those frames have to become moving shots.
If you want to take finished Procreate frames further, is one tool to look at. Your Procreate frames stay the creative source, and the compositing stays where you already do it.
FAQ
Where is the ColorDrop threshold slider in Procreate? It has no permanent place in the interface. It appears as a thin blue bar above the canvas only while you hold your finger or Pencil down after dropping a color into an area.
Does a higher threshold fill more or less? More. Dragging right raises the threshold and fills a larger area. Dragging left lowers it and fills less.
Why does my fill leave a white fringe around lines? The threshold is probably too low for anti-aliased edges. Raise it gradually until the fringe closes, stopping before the fill leaks.
Does Procreate remember the threshold? Yes. It keeps the last value you used, so check it before each new fill.
Can I fill on a different layer from my line art? Yes. Set the line art layer as the Reference layer, then ColorDrop on a layer beneath it.